Hello Darth,
I think the director of the CDC making a statement qualifies as a CDC statement.
He said “the cost” has been more teen deaths from suicide than COVID. In one sense, the statement is meaningless since practically no *healthy* teens have died of COVID. And if they are committing suicide over the virus then they are tragically misinformed.
The “cost” is the cost of the policy: many teens of HS age have been separated from their peers and there’s a high correlation between social isolation and risk for suicide.
And these unnecessary deaths are occurring in a population that has a slightly higher than 13 months of life left on this earth.
COVID Reality.
OK, so Dr. Redfield is the CDC Director.
He was appointed by Donald Trump after Trump's first appointment had to resign in disgrace.
Dr. Redfield has been criticized for his handling of the crisis.
"Dr. William Foege doesn't know how his private letter to the director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Robert Redfield, got leaked — but he stands by its contents.
"I think we've got about the worst response to this pandemic that you could possibly have," said Foege, who served as CDC director from 1977 to 1983, spanning the Carter and Reagan administrations, in an interview with NPR. "
Past CDC Director Urges Current One To Stand Up To Trump
What I see here is a cherry-picked fact meant to support Donald Trump's lax handling of the crisis.
OK, so more teens are dying from suicides than have died from COVID.
That sounds very believable to me. But let's put that in context to better understand why the full story is not told by that soundbyte.
Teens have been committing suicide for a long time. It's a big problem that existed prior to the pandemic. If more teens are still dying from suicide than COVID that simply reflects that not many young people die from COVID, and teens continue to kill themselves at greater rates as they have in the past.
The one fact which has not been said is whether or not teen suicides are increased now, and by how much.
Regardless of any increase (a fact which has been omitted as a part of the cherry-picking,) the fact remains that we need to continue to do social distancing, and teens need to comply just as much as all other humans because whether or not they are strongly afflicted by the disease they still get the disease, become carriers whether they show symptoms or not, and they could easily transmit the disease to others who could die from it.
Distancing for teens is not a matter of trying to prevent teen COVID deaths. It is matter of reducing the transmission of the disease and slowing the spread until we have an effective vaccine widely available. We are trying to buy time.
Teen suicides is a completely different matter that needs to be addressed by good parenting and possible intervention. We simply cannot abandon the three W's because teens struggle to understand the gravity of the macroscopic picture.
Asymptomatic carriers of the disease can infect other people and cause them to die.
We must limit contact between humans.
Humans packed in a classroom for extended duration is simply not a good idea right now.
This disease has affected everybody's daily lives.
If you are human, you need to do your part to fight the disease.
The humans who resist the wise measures are actually helping the disease to spread further.
This is war. It's the humans against the bug. We need to all be together on the side of the humans.
Don't be on the side of the bug.
The virus will not reward you.
The virus has no brain.
We humans have brains.
We need to use them.