US citizen executed during Israeli flotilla raid

Why do conservatives salivate at the thought of cold-blooded killing? All conservatives are killers in my mind, and are worse than the worse murderer, because a murderer usually at least has insanity as a mitigating factor, while a conservative is just a killer because it gives them sadistic pleasure.
 
No, you misunderstood what I posted, which was probably my fault for structuring the sentence incorrectly. Since 1967, thousands of Israelis have died as a result of indiscriminate bombing by the Palestinians. But the actual number of people who have been killed, has nothing to do with how much right Israel has to defend itself.

Well this is what you said.

They established this blockade for a legitimate reason, Hezbollah was smuggling rockets into Gaza, and they were being launched into Israel, killing thousands of innocent citizens on a daily basis.
 
I see the Ministry of Truth is hard at work explaining why 9 unarmed civilians died at the hands of their troops in international waters where they had every right to be.

1) No... they do not have the right to run a blockade.

2) Those unarmed civilians died because they attacked the Israelis boarding... notice how the other six ships didn't seem to have a problem?

3) The leaders of the 'humanitarian' mission recognized that Israel would try to stop them if they tried to run the blockade.
 
Far from "whining", Dix, i'm just asking why they won't release the footage in its entirety. You've confidence in their arguments, their assurances of legality, the assurances that they were acting in self-defence. I don't know what happened, that's why i'd like the Israeli's to just prove everybody wrong by revealing all the evidence.

Why would you have a problem with that?

I would concur. The full/unedited video should be released (at a minimum to a group made up of the conflicting parties and international mediators) for review.

I have already made clear my position on the legality of the boarding on other threads, so for this one I will provide my guess as to what happened on board. Note... for all... do pay attention to the word GUESS.

Sequence of events.... (again... my GUESS on number 7)

1) Israel and Egypt make public their intent to blockade Gaza for security reasons

2) A short while ago, the IHH declares its intent to deliver aid to Gaza by running said blockade

3) Israel responds by stating it will deter any attempt to run the blockade and instead offers its port for delivery of said aid which can be inspected and then trucked into Gaza (assuming no contraband).

4) IHH refuses that option and states its continued intent to run the blockade.

5) Israel restates its intent to deny the flotilla from porting in Gaza

6) the inevitable happens... the Israelis disable five ships and take them to Israeli port without incident. The sixth ship, with roughly 600 'humanitarians' is boarded.

7) Upon hitting the deck, the Israeli's are attacked with sticks, pipes and reportedly knives. As fighting ensues between the two parties, the Israelis become panicked due to being grossly outnumbered, despite possessing the greater fire power. They switch from the paintball guns to live fire from pistols. At some point in the melee pistols are taken from some of the Israeli's and used against them. End result... nine violent 'humanitarians' dead, many on both sides wounded.
 
I would concur. The full/unedited video should be released (at a minimum to a group made up of the conflicting parties and international mediators) for review.

I think the world would be a lot better off if the world finally opened it's eyes and realised that our benevolent dictatorship is the answer to all the world's problems. :)
 
Why do conservatives salivate at the thought of cold-blooded killing? All conservatives are killers in my mind, and are worse than the worse murderer, because a murderer usually at least has insanity as a mitigating factor, while a conservative is just a killer because it gives them sadistic pleasure.

Was Mow, Hitler and Stalin conservatives? Now that's the ones I really want to avoid.
 
1) No... they do not have the right to run a blockade.

2) Those unarmed civilians died because they attacked the Israelis boarding... notice how the other six ships didn't seem to have a problem?

3) The leaders of the 'humanitarian' mission recognized that Israel would try to stop them if they tried to run the blockade.



Navi Pillay says that the blockade is illegal and I agree with her.

http://uk.news.yahoo.com/4/20100605/twl-un-high-commissioner-gaza-blockade-i-41f21e0.html
 
I think the world would be a lot better off if the world finally opened it's eyes and realised that our benevolent dictatorship is the answer to all the world's problems. :)

Actually, if we look back, it was your imperial tampering that put us in this mess to begin with. Perhaps we should unite the world against you.
 
Actually, if we look back, it was your imperial tampering that put us in this mess to begin with. Perhaps we should unite the world against you.

Yes, the charver Empire, during its short life, has caused almost all of the world's problems.
 


From your article...


"International humanitarian law prohibits starvation of civilians as a method of warfare and ... it is also prohibited to impose collective punishment on civilians."

The above is true. Now again turn to the fact that had the humanitarians subjected the cargo to port in Israel, be inspected, it could have been delivered to Gaza. Israel may be stopping some items of question, but they are letting aid through.

"I have consistently reported to member states that the blockade is illegal and must be lifted."

Which is her OPINION... it obviously isn't based on law... otherwise she would not have continued...

She said that even if the blockade is proven legal under international law, Israel's military operation against the flotilla on Monday must be analysed from the perspective of Israel's obligation to allow humanitarian aid into Gaza.

The above is comical... Israel's actions must be analyzed from the perspective of Israel allowing aid through to Gaza??????

What planet is she living on? Israel said the cargo could go on to Gaza after a port inspection in Israel. Hence... the aid... minus any contraband (if any existed) was all to be delivered to Gaza. Meaning the military action only occurred because the 'humanitarians' goal was a confrontation with Israel.
 
Back
Top