I'm Watermark
Diabetic
In response to Howey and RazorX:
The world is far too complex to make these broad statements about responsibility. I'll present you with some scenarios. Someone goes skydiving, has problems with his parachute, and breaks his legs as a result. He looses his job at the factory, and can't pay the bills. Is that his fault? Someone else is in a relationship, gets pregnant, decides to keep the kid, and quits her job to take care of it. Their significant other looses their job, or maybe they divorce. Is that her fault? What about if a couple moves into a new home a few blocks from a factory, they get terribly sick, and the water is later discovered to carcinogenic? Is that their fault? How about if someone grows up in a poor neighborhood, get average grades, and can't go to college because they need to help support their family? Is it their fault that they end up working a minimum wage job?
The answer isn't yes, or no to any of these questions. They could have all been conceivably prevented, but externalities also played a role. You need to remember that the world is a huge web of choice and consequence, but also of chance, and the effects the activities of other human beings have on their fellows. To simply write off the fact that we're social animals who live in societies, and to say our actions are solely a product of our own deficiencies and capabilities, is to deny the very foundation of how we organize ourselves.
The world is far too complex to make these broad statements about responsibility. I'll present you with some scenarios. Someone goes skydiving, has problems with his parachute, and breaks his legs as a result. He looses his job at the factory, and can't pay the bills. Is that his fault? Someone else is in a relationship, gets pregnant, decides to keep the kid, and quits her job to take care of it. Their significant other looses their job, or maybe they divorce. Is that her fault? What about if a couple moves into a new home a few blocks from a factory, they get terribly sick, and the water is later discovered to carcinogenic? Is that their fault? How about if someone grows up in a poor neighborhood, get average grades, and can't go to college because they need to help support their family? Is it their fault that they end up working a minimum wage job?
The answer isn't yes, or no to any of these questions. They could have all been conceivably prevented, but externalities also played a role. You need to remember that the world is a huge web of choice and consequence, but also of chance, and the effects the activities of other human beings have on their fellows. To simply write off the fact that we're social animals who live in societies, and to say our actions are solely a product of our own deficiencies and capabilities, is to deny the very foundation of how we organize ourselves.