Can anyone make a cogent case for how birthright citizenship is good for America?

Libhater said:
Your signature statement should say 'No Leftist Communist Movement' as Trump is currently destroying that Leftist movement.
Who is your rising star in your Communist Party? Would it be the Communist anti Semite ZOHRAN MAMDANI who is vying to
become N.Y.C.'s next mayor?
Click to expand...
You need to lay-off the drugs.
 
Libhater said:
I didn't realize that the lefty communist barely graduated from high school. However, he seems to be quite efficient in his
support for communist ideals as he's trying to incorporate them into N.Y.C.'s highly radical leftist agenda.
Click to expand...
You must of graduated from Trump university.
 
Poor Richard Saunders said:
We don't punish children for the crimes of the parents.
Click to expand...
That isn't. It's not rewarding the parents for their crime. The child being born is still born either way. The child doesn't need to be a citizen of the United States regardless of the citizenship of the parents. In this case, the parents being foreigners deliberately set out to have their child in the US in contravention of US immigration law with the knowing intent the child would become a US citizen and that would confer benefits and advantages to the parents.

If the child weren't to become a US citizen, the child would still be a citizen of the nation the parents were from so there's no loss there to the child. It isn't as if the child chose where to be born.

Your argument is the child having been born in the US, by no action of its own, is harmed by not being made a citizen. That's absurd. The child isn't harmed by not being made a citizen. The parents retain responsibility, and the parents gain no benefit from the child's place of birth which is THE ONLY REASON THEY KNOWINGLY CHOSE TO HAVE THE CHILD IN THE US! That is, the parents are the one benefiting from their crime.
 
ULTRA MAGA said:
Not asking to debate the constitution. Forget about that for a minute. Or the intent of the 14th.

And without mentioning DJT.

The stand alone question is: Exactly in what way is it beneficial to America and Americans to have the babies of illegal aliens automatically be citizens?

Go ahead and list the ways it's detrimental too if you're a naysayer to the concept.
Click to expand...
I can tell you that America has survived for centuries with birthright citizenship being the way it is. It's only an issue for you because it "trolls the libs". My bus boy does not wish to kill me. You fuckers are fucking looney!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top