There are 125 players on a team every year. I have been a fan since the 60s. Unless there is some situation I am not aware of, that leaves a LOT of young men who did NOT fit the description. Several of the coaches (during my lifetime) have benched or banned quality players because of issues relating to violations of rules. An example of what I have referring to is Bear Bryant suspended Joe Namath for the final 2 games of the '63 season. In '64 Namath was a key factor in Bama winning the national championship. Coach Bryant once called Namath "the greatest athlete I ever coached". But Joe broke the rules so Joe sat on the bench.
Of course there couldn't possibly be a situation that you aren't aware of, could there?
Was Broadway Joe better or worse than Johnny Football?