Yeah there are some pretty strict rules for nationwide class action suits. It will be interesting to see if the left met all of the standards.
Activist Federal judge blocks Trump's birthright citizenship ban for all infants, testing lower court powers
- Thread starter Truth Detector
- Start date
You're the idiot who thinks the US Constitution grants it.
You're the idiot who thought Canada grants it.
It's "you're" not "your" idiot.
Not really. It's a third world shit hole no one would want to become a citizen in. Not the US. Not Canada.
It does apparently. But it's not the US and not Canada.
I guess I assumed that other nations had common sense and intelligent policies. My bad. But they are not the US and not Canada idiot.
I should have qualified that with "NO SANE COUNTRY" allows birthright citizenship.
T. A. Gardner
Thread Killer
Which Countries Offer Birthright Citizenship in 2025?
The United States faces unprecedented challenges to birthright citizenship through new legislation and executive orders, risking citizenship for children of undocumented immigrants. Canada continues unconditional birthright citizenship, emphasizing inclusion. The debate involves legal battles...
www.visaverge.com
Countries with Birthright Citizenship - Vivid Maps
Birthright citizenship (Jus soli) is a legislative policy under which any child born within a country's border is automatically given citizenship in that country, even if their parents are not citizens. Currently, 35 nations in the world have unrestricted birthright citizenship.
vividmaps.com
Birthright Citizenship: Do countries around the world offer automatic citizenship to people born on their land? Here’s list of nations which do and the ones don’t
Most countries in the Americas give automatic citizenship to people born on their land called birthright citizenship. The US led this practice, which many nearby countries followed. However, Europe, Asia and Africa have restrictions. Only a few countries in these regions allow citizenship by...
T. A. Gardner
Thread Killer
To get a class action, nationwide, lawsuit going takes anywhere from months to years. You have to have numerous plaintiffs, often with separate cases in different districts, with highly similar cases to bring one. This is difficult and costly to do compared to simply having one plaintiff before one judge who then rules nationwide. That's pretty quick and simple to do. It also allows judge shopping to occur as the plaintiff can usually file in a district court of their choice.
I saw that site, it is wrong. Canada does not have birthright citizenship for the same reason many other countries do not.Which Countries Offer Birthright Citizenship in 2025?
The United States faces unprecedented challenges to birthright citizenship through new legislation and executive orders, risking citizenship for children of undocumented immigrants. Canada continues unconditional birthright citizenship, emphasizing inclusion. The debate involves legal battles...
Countries with Birthright Citizenship - Vivid Maps
Birthright citizenship (Jus soli) is a legislative policy under which any child born within a country's border is automatically given citizenship in that country, even if their parents are not citizens. Currently, 35 nations in the world have unrestricted birthright citizenship.
Birthright Citizenship: Do countries around the world offer automatic citizenship to people born on their land? Here’s list of nations which do and the ones don’t
Most countries in the Americas give automatic citizenship to people born on their land called birthright citizenship. The US led this practice, which many nearby countries followed. However, Europe, Asia and Africa have restrictions. Only a few countries in these regions allow citizenship by...economictimes.indiatimes.com
What is your point?
....which is also unconstitutional and not considered with judicial temperance or the law.
T. A. Gardner
Thread Killer
That is why I gave multiple sites. As a general rule only countries in the Americas offer birthright citizenship while those in Europe, Africa, and Asia don't.
The 14th amendment is in the Constitution. The courts decide the meaning of the law and the Constitution when there are questions as to that meaning.
You sure are showing us a lot of blabbering and flailing.
Well a district Federal Judge has already given them an injunction based on a class action suit filed in his court. What remains now to see is if he followed the rules or not.
T. A. Gardner
Thread Killer
It has been widely practiced, particularly by the Left, up to that Supreme Court ruling because for the first time in US history, district courts were issuing nationwide injunctions like parking tickets against Trump.
Nationwide injunctions ordered against the first Trump administration account for more than half of the total injunctions ordered against the federal government since 1963, data show.
Number of injunctions halting Trump policies trounces predecessors by double
More than half of the 127 nationwide injunctions issued against the federal government since 1963 targeted the Trump administration, data show.
www.foxnews.com
A single federal judge in Texas issues an order, and suddenly a new White House policy on immigration or environmental protection freezes across the entire country.
With the stroke of a pen, one of America’s more than 600 federal district judges could halt enforcement of federal laws, regulations, or executive orders against everyone in the United States—not just the people who filed the lawsuit.
How One Judge Could Stop the Government: The Rise and Fall of the Nationwide Injunction
A single federal judge in Texas issues an order, and suddenly a new White House policy on immigration or environmental protection freezes across the entire country. With the stroke of a pen, one of America’s more than 600 federal district judges could halt enforcement of federal laws...
govfacts.org
The Left, as always, overplayed their hand and now have been smacked down for it. They destroyed standing legal doctrine by assuming that it could be used with impunity against Trump and nothing adverse would happen in return.
But upon further investigation, countries listed actually do not. Canada being the big one.
There are several factors that can affect your eligibility for German citizenship. One of the most important factors is your ancestry, as you may be eligible for citizenship by descent if one or both of your parents are German citizens. Another factor is your residency status, as you may be eligible for citizenship through naturalization if you have lived in Germany for a certain amount of time.
Other factors that can impact your eligibility include your age, criminal record, language skills, and financial stability. It’s important to understand these factors and how they may affect your chances of obtaining German citizenship. By knowing what is required of you, you can take the necessary steps to become a citizen and enjoy all the benefits that come with it.
I was Born in Germany, Can I Get Citizenship? - Know Germany
If you were born in Germany, you may be wondering if you are eligible for German citizenship. To find out, it’s important to understand the German
knowgermany.com
T. A. Gardner
Thread Killer
I see another Supreme Court smackdown coming soon...
Switching to class action lawsuits and having judges issue a nationwide injunction immediately is likely to get the same treatment doing it for a single plaintiff got. The Left simply doesn't learn.
Wrong. The ultimate arbiter of constitutionality resides with the Supreme court.
Courts may interpret the Constitution, but they are not the ultimate deciders.
So, what is your point brainless wonder?
Projection
The process of displacing one’s feelings onto a different person, animal, or object. The term is most commonly used to describe defensive projection—attributing one’s own unacceptable urges to another.
Per the bolded, the left does not have the capacity to learn, nor do they care to learn. They are autocratic ideologues who believe they know what is best for everyone, elections be damned.
T. A. Gardner
Thread Killer
Most of Europe is something like that. In Switzerland, your neighbors have to vouch for you that you are sufficiently "Swiss" in how you act and whatnot for example.But upon further investigation, countries listed actually do not. Canada being the big one.
There are several factors that can affect your eligibility for German citizenship. One of the most important factors is your ancestry, as you may be eligible for citizenship by descent if one or both of your parents are German citizens. Another factor is your residency status, as you may be eligible for citizenship through naturalization if you have lived in Germany for a certain amount of time.
Other factors that can impact your eligibility include your age, criminal record, language skills, and financial stability. It’s important to understand these factors and how they may affect your chances of obtaining German citizenship. By knowing what is required of you, you can take the necessary steps to become a citizen and enjoy all the benefits that come with it.
I was Born in Germany, Can I Get Citizenship? - Know Germany
If you were born in Germany, you may be wondering if you are eligible for German citizenship. To find out, it’s important to understand the German
I know a Federal Judge for the Northern District of Texas very well and he said he has never issued a national injunction and would never do so.It has been widely practiced, particularly by the Left, up to that Supreme Court ruling because for the first time in US history, district courts were issuing nationwide injunctions like parking tickets against Trump.
Nationwide injunctions ordered against the first Trump administration account for more than half of the total injunctions ordered against the federal government since 1963, data show.
Number of injunctions halting Trump policies trounces predecessors by double
More than half of the 127 nationwide injunctions issued against the federal government since 1963 targeted the Trump administration, data show.
A single federal judge in Texas issues an order, and suddenly a new White House policy on immigration or environmental protection freezes across the entire country.
With the stroke of a pen, one of America’s more than 600 federal district judges could halt enforcement of federal laws, regulations, or executive orders against everyone in the United States—not just the people who filed the lawsuit.
How One Judge Could Stop the Government: The Rise and Fall of the Nationwide Injunction
A single federal judge in Texas issues an order, and suddenly a new White House policy on immigration or environmental protection freezes across the entire country. With the stroke of a pen, one of America’s more than 600 federal district judges could halt enforcement of federal laws...
The Left, as always, overplayed their hand and now have been smacked down for it. They destroyed standing legal doctrine by assuming that it could be used with impunity against Trump and nothing adverse would happen in return.
I think you are correct. The Left can't seem to be able to stop themselves.
T. A. Gardner
Thread Killer
Gay marriage is a great example of that. It was made the law of the land by judicial fiat. Back when it was being debated, it ended up on 35 state's ballots in one form or another put there by the Left. The Left said, "We'll let the people decide and we're good with the outcome." In all 35 cases, including in California of all places, it was shot down often overwhelmingly.
The Left then said, "The people are idiots! They don't know what's good for them!" They went to court and got every one of those ballot initiatives overturned by activist judges--In California a gay judge who actively supported gay marriage overturned it--and it somehow became the law of the land.
That sort of thing shouldn't happen in a 'democracy.'
Which side of the issue are you arguing? The 14th applied to Native Americans not associated with a tribe in 1870. Tribes were wards of the US government. They received government assistance. They had treaties. Tribes were responsible for policing criminal acts committed on a tribal member by another tribal member. Tribes were not subject to the jurisdiction of the US or the states where they were located.
Did you bother to read the Dawes Act? Apparently not.
The Dawes Act granted land to Native Americans. Upon accepting the land, they became taxed. Since they were not citizens at that time, accepting the land made them naturalized citizens of the state and of the US. None of those that accepted land or their descendants needed the Snyder act to become citizens.
I am curious as to how many adult native Americans you think there were in 1877 that were born after the 14th amendment was ratified in 1868.
The 14th amendment allowed some Native Americans to be citizens at birth.
The Dawes Act allowed more Native Americans to be citizens at birth.
The Snyder Act allowed ALL Native Americans to be citizens at birth.
I was born in Germany. My mom was German but became a US citizen prior to my birth and my dad was US military. I was born an American citizen, and not automatically a German citizen.
Because of my mom's German background and my being born in Germany, I could get a German citizenship and passport. But there is still a process for that.