Head of Hamas government in Gaza eliminated

[IBDaMann]

There is no genocide.

Denial, to support a special pleading fallacy, leading to an absurd conflation.

Hamas is not a signatory to the Convention.

This would be irrelevant even if Hamas were still alive. Notice how you cannot bring yourself to acknowledge that Israel is a signatory to the very convention that defines its war crimes. Your argument is as pathetic as they come.

 

[Into the Night]

Denial,

Void reference fallacy.

to support a special pleading fallacy, leading to an absurd conflation.

Fallacy fallacy.

This would be irrelevant even if Hamas were still alive.

It is, though there's not much left of it.

Notice how you cannot bring yourself to acknowledge that Israel is a signatory to the very convention that defines its war crimes. Your argument is as pathetic as they come.

What 'war crimes'???

 

[IBDaMann]

What 'war crimes'???

The ones you are denying that Israel signed up to never commit, the ones defined in the IV Geneva Convention and the Convention against Genocide to which Israel is a signatory. You are well aware that the existence of others who are not signatories to these conventions does not somehow alleviate Israel of the moral and legal obligation to adhere to these laws that they signed and ratified, laws that obligate them to behave in certain manners, and to refrain from behaving in certain manners, even with regards to those who are not signatories.

Israel is not permitted to commit war crimes against non-signatories of these Conventions, despite your belief that Israel always warrants special pleading. Israel is not permitted to launch air strikes on public population centers; that is illegal everywhere and Israel does not get any special pleading. Israel was required to actively protect every single civilian in Gaza, just as if they were actively protecting Israelis in Israel, from the moment the first ITF soldier set foot in Gaza, and to provide special protections (defined and delineated in the Conventions) to women and to children ages 14 and under, and to ensure that all civilians had access to safe shelter, food, clean water, necessary medical care and supplies, and to all other basic necessities; instead, the ITF began immediately mowing them all down indiscriminantly with helicopter gunships, including women and children to whom they were supposed to be providing special protections. The ITF committed thousands of violations of the relevant Conventions within the first few days. You are supporting an horrific genocide.

You weren't even bothered by the daily requirement to fish dozens of children out of rubble; in fact, you became angered at the idea of being deprived of this pleasure. You rebuked me for merely pointing out the ongoing body count of children that were then dead who were alive and well before the ITF began their 2nd Nakba. As the numbers became steady at hundreds of children being wasted by the ITF each and every week, all you could manage was to express how those children somehow totally deserved it. I will never join you in your desire for Arabs to be ethnically cleansed. Your pretense at ignorance that genocide before you is even occurring is sickening.

 

[T. A. Gardner]

Head of Hamas government in Gaza eliminated​

What? Again? WTF? How many times does Israel have to whack this guy?

 

[Into the Night]

The ones you are denying that Israel signed up to never commit, the ones defined in the IV Geneva Convention and the Convention against Genocide to which Israel is a signatory.

Not a war crime. What war crimes???

You are well aware that the existence of others who are not signatories to these conventions does not somehow alleviate Israel of the moral and legal obligation to adhere to these laws that they signed and ratified, laws that obligate them to behave in certain manners, and to refrain from behaving in certain manners, even with regards to those who are not signatories.

Not a war crime. What war crimes???

Israel is not permitted to commit war crimes

What war crimes???

against non-signatories of these Conventions, despite your belief that Israel always warrants special pleading.

Fallacy fallacy.

Israel is not permitted to launch air strikes on public population centers;

Yes it is. They are at war.

that is illegal everywhere and Israel does not get any special pleading.

Fallacy fallacy. They are at war.

Israel was required to actively protect every single civilian in Gaza,

Dead wrong. They are at war.

just as if they were actively protecting Israelis in Israel,

They are.

from the moment the first ITF soldier set foot in Gaza, and to provide special protections (defined and delineated in the Conventions) to women and to children ages 14 and under,

Special pleading fallacy. Nothing requires them to protect anyone that is military or part of a military installation, regardless of their age.

and to ensure that all civilians had access to safe shelter, food, clean water, necessary medical care and supplies,

Not required unless they are captured.

and to all other basic necessities; instead, the ITF began immediately mowing them all down indiscriminantly with helicopter gunships, including women and children to whom they were supposed to be providing special protections. The ITF committed thousands of violations of the relevant Conventions within the first few days. You are supporting an horrific genocide.

There is no genocide. They are NOT required to protect any military target.

You weren't even bothered by the daily requirement to fish dozens of children out of rubble;

That's war. I never said I liked war.

in fact, you became angered at the idea of being deprived of this pleasure. You rebuked me for merely pointing out the ongoing body count of children that were then dead who were alive and well before the ITF began their 2nd Nakba.

Because you were making up numbers and using them as 'data'. Argument from randU fallacy.

As the numbers became steady at hundreds of children being wasted by the ITF each and every week, all you could manage was to express how those children somehow totally deserved it.

Many did. They were military.

I will never join you in your desire for Arabs to be ethnically cleansed.

There is no 'ethnic cleansing' of Arabs.

Your pretense at ignorance that genocide before you is even occurring is sickening.

There is no genocide.