Logic is nothing without metaphysics

Hume said:
The laws of logic are believed to be the basis of rational thought. But what grounds logic itself? Surely logic cannot be grounded in logic, for that would be circular reasoning, and therefore illogical. Yale Professor Jacob McNulty argues there is no logical foundation for logic. Instead we should look to Hegel for a solution to this dilemma, according to which logic is derived from metaphysics.
iai.tv

Logic is nothing without metaphysics: Hegel and the birth of logic from being | Jacob McNulty

iai.tv iai.tv
Click to expand...
you're an idiot.
 
serenity said:
Rational thoughts are incomplete narratives used ancestrally to govern outcomes of each generation gap alive daily here so far about living eternally separated while genetically inhabiting space daily.

Let me break this down. The physical time the planet rotates each time is 3 minutes and 56 seconds less than the intellectual 24/7 space time continuum is defined by humanity since dawn of civilization started corrupting evey great great grandchild lived since conception replacing its specific 30 ancestors lived previous 4 generations as their 16 great great grandparents, 8 great grandparents, 4 grandparents, 2 creating the conception of each great great grandchild in the whole populaiton living daily here.

Series parallel time the fifth generation gap added develops into the next 2 parenting generation of 5th generation gap added as the original 16 great great grandparents died off after been 1 of 2 parents of the following 4 generations carrying their chromosomes in inverted proportions of thermodynamic use of periodic elements sustaining forms shaped universally here now as norganic universal positions and ancestral displacements inhabiting with the specificity of eacy existing at the same time never same total sum twice, now
Click to expand...
You might be attempting to convey a complex idea about the interplay between time, genetics, and human existence, but the message is so garbled that extracting a clear, logical argument or point from it is nearly impossible for this 'less intelligent' member. If this is meant to be a serious inquiry or statement, it really needs significant clarification to be understood or debated rationally.

Can you clarify how you believe the discrepancy between physical Earth rotation time and human-defined time relates to the genetic evolution across generations, where each person's unique genetic makeup from ancestors is somehow tied to thermodynamic principles and the periodic table, suggesting a universal pattern where no two generations are exactly the same?

I'm really trying to understand for some unknown reason, but what the hell.
 
Tobytone said:
You might be attempting to convey a complex idea about the interplay between time, genetics, and human existence, but the message is so garbled that extracting a clear, logical argument or point from it is nearly impossible for this 'less intelligent' member. If this is meant to be a serious inquiry or statement, it really needs significant clarification to be understood or debated rationally.

Can you clarify how you believe the discrepancy between physical Earth rotation time and human-defined time relates to the genetic evolution across generations, where each person's unique genetic makeup from ancestors is somehow tied to thermodynamic principles and the periodic table, suggesting a universal pattern where no two generations are exactly the same?

I'm really trying to understand for some unknown reason, but what the hell.
Click to expand...
'serenity' is mentally ill. He posts nothing but nonsense, for years.
 
Tobytone said:
You might be attempting to convey a complex idea about the interplay between time, genetics, and human existence, but the message is so garbled that extracting a clear, logical argument or point from it is nearly impossible for this 'less intelligent' member. If this is meant to be a serious inquiry or statement, it really needs significant clarification to be understood or debated rationally.

Can you clarify how you believe the discrepancy between physical Earth rotation time and human-defined time relates to the genetic evolution across generations, where each person's unique genetic makeup from ancestors is somehow tied to thermodynamic principles and the periodic table, suggesting a universal pattern where no two generations are exactly the same?

I'm really trying to understand for some unknown reason, but what the hell.
Click to expand...
Good luck!

:cheers:
 
Cypress said:
Seems perfectly self evident to me that the principles of logic, the laws of physics, and mathematics itself exist independently of the human brain, in what might be called a metaphysical, Platonic, or ontological reality.
Click to expand...
This is essentially philosophical realism, where an objective existence is independent of whether humans recognize or understand them. It is contrary to a more nominalist view where these principles are considered human inventions or useful fictions. At least we're dealing with a real debate of legitimate differences of thought.

I haven't really come down on either side, due to an overall lack of interest in the answer. Either way we have and apply these principles regardless of their genesis, just as I love and eat eggs regardless of whether the chicken or the egg came first.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top