Ok then explain that?
How does a society ever know who is the 'best singular one", when individuals in society will value different aspects of the various resumes?
it seems to me you are saying meaningless things. "There is no singular qualified one"..."but there is a singular best one..."
Flesh that out.
You are the POTUS and looking for the singular best SCOTUS candidate to nominate... the single best FBI head... etc... how do you find and isolate that single best one?
Walk me thru that process if you, in fact think it is something that can be done and should be done so that only the singular best one is ever chosen.
First of all, I can't think of an easier way to say that there is probably more than one qualified candidate, but perhaps only one best candidate.
These concepts are not in conflict, even minutely.
There's nothing to explain here--I'm just using English words in a totally logical and cogent sequence.
You don't seem to be grasping concepts that seem very straightforward too me.
Perhaps you are understanding and I'm the one misunderstanding your comments.
Second, these are not group decisions.
These are not societal decisions.
These are decisions left to one individual to make.
In evaluating qualities and qualification, the sole individual charged with making the decision
is going to prioritize the importance of each quality and qualification according to his/her/its personal values.
I would definitely have diversity on that list of important considerations,
and it would be well down the list below many things that I would consider even more important.
Those are my personal values.
Somebody else may have different priorities than I,
and in Newsom's case,
I was merely pointing out that I disagreed with his priorities.
Somebody else might on the other hand agree with his priorities.
Mainly, though, the concept that there may be several qualified candidates who could successfully fill the position,
and yet among them,
one checks the most important boxes in the opinion of the person making the decision
shouldn't be a difficult one to grasp.