What was bad about the Iran Deal?

Said this before, it would be of zero surprise to me if we learned CFM was really a left-wing troll and TTQ64 a right-wing troll. Both playing the worst caricatures of the "other" side.

Don't bet on it. It would be a surprise if you actually listened to what was said when I told you I don't play games.
 
I don't know much about the deal and what was bad or good about it. What I really, really didn't like was Obama sending Iran $1.7 billion in cash. It had the stench of a ransom he was trying to hide from the public.

Without knowing all the details, that alone makes Obama's deal (not the gubmint's) with Iran stink to high heaven.

IT WAS IRANS MONEY YOU FUCKING BRAIN DEAD FUCK
 
fuck you


Obama and our allies put this agreement together


Kerry is a war hero you evil fucking traitor to the nation

Kerry is a traitor.

If Obama had anything to do with it, it's automatically a failure. When a POS like him puts something together, it can't be anything but shit.
 
yes. i recall that. Iran has been Ok if not great without doing business with the USA.

It looks like Europe will continue to do so.Iran has a military force in Syria, as well as their proxies Hezbollah.
The Houthi's ( Iran proxies in Yemen) just shot off 4 missiles at Riyadh

The biggest miscalculation by Obama was that the deal was going to do anything.
A couple years breakout time one way or the other doesn't matter.
We just gave them a bunch of money and took off sanctions for little return

Yes the region will almost surely go towards proliferation; if Iran as a signatory of the non-Proliferation Agreement can get nukes : any one can.

The biggest miscalculation by Trump is that cancelling the deal makes any real difference to Iran.
They have all kinds o commercial ties now that the agreement let them get going.

Iran is a regional power -quickly nuclear. It's a geopolitical allie of Russia;
but calls it's own shots in the ME.

Iran is now the dominate in the Shi'a corridor. This is how it's going to be in the foreseeable future -
no matter what we do
Nukes don't really change anything all that much.

PS. Israel will now go after Iranian military targets in Syria

What has Iran accomplished in the past 50 years? Has Death to America or Death to Israel helped them?
 
seriously dude

it broke

you are not making any sense at all

No, you're just too fucking stupid to realize you're being mocked for being a fool. That's what hanging around with the kind you hang around with will do. The stupid rubbed off on you.
 
Will one of you Rumppers please tell me what good it does to pull out of the Iran deal?

A better question would be what good does it do to stay in the deal? Of course, we also have to pretend that you actually care about getting the facts when they are readily available to your finger tips, yet you feign ignorance on the topic.

I think the left needs to decide if they are only in this for Barrack Hussien Obama, or are they in it to protect Americans, our allies and Israel.

Here goes:

#1 President Barack Obama never submitted his Iranian nuclear deal for ratification by the Congress because he knew it would have no chance of passing. The Iranian parliament has never approved it either (that body passed a heavily amended version) and the Iranian president has never signed it. The Iranian cabinet has never even discussed it.

#2 Obama and his Secretary of State John Kerry claim that their nuke deal with the "moderate faction" in Tehran might encourage positive changes in Iran's behavior. That hasn't happened. Instead, Iran has acted with impunity, safe in the knowledge that Obama will minimize and talk around its violations, lest his centerpiece foreign policy accomplishment prove illusory.

#3 The Obama administration accepted a pledge in the agreement with Iran that it did not have to disclose its past nuclear weapons work or fully cooperate with the IAEA investigation in order to receive sanctions relief.

#4 Certain that Obama is unwilling to undermine the nonexistent "deal," the mullahs have intensified their backing for Houthi rebels in Yemen and heightened their propaganda war against Saudi Arabia, now openly calling for the overthrow of the monarchy there.

#5 since the agreement was signed, Iran has continued to flout the U.N. not only by giving arms to Yemen and Syria but also sending Gen. Qasem Soleimani, chief of Iran's elite military Qods Force, and other sanctioned officials to Russia, Iraq and elsewhere and by refusing to fully cooperate with the IAEA investigation into its nuclear weapons research.

Lastly; Obama never submitted the Iranian nuclear deal for ratification. He knew it would have no chance of passing in Congress. Instead it will go down in American history as one of the most counterproductive diplomatic efforts by any American administration.


https://www.usnews.com/news/the-rep...clear-deal-is-a-bad-deal-off-to-a-worse-start
 


Answer: The actual hostage deal that in fact accounts for the cash payment, which President Obama said on Thursday was not a ransom.
The currency shipped to Iran in the dead of night drew attention from presidential candidate Donald Trump this week, who on Friday appeared to walk back an earlier assertion that he had seen a payment being delivered. But that money was owed to the Islamic Republic since 1979, the year the U.S. froze all the Iranian funds in American banks as retribution for seizure of the U.S. embassy in Tehran, as revolution swept that nation.

What was universally known as the Iran hostage crisis went on for more than a year, and finally ended with a bargain: In exchange for the release of 52 American diplomats and citizens, both sides agreed to resolve the question of money through international arbitration. The Iran-United States Claims Tribunal has trudged along for almost four decades now, and the money has flowed both ways. By 1983, Iran had returned $896 million to U.S. banks, which in turn had returned hundreds of millions in frozen funds to Iran. Today, private claims from the U.S. side have been resolved to the tune of $2.1 billion.
But still at issue as Obama began his second term was $400 million that Iran in the late 1970s had paid for U.S. fighter jets, while Tehran was still a U.S. ally. After it turned into an enemy in 1979, Washington was not about to deliver the jets. But, all these years later, Iran wanted its money back—and with interest.
Get your history fix in one place: sign up for the weekly TIME History newsletter
All told, Tehran was asking The Hague arbitrators (comprising equal numbers of U.S., Iranian and neutral judges) for $10 billion. Fearing they might actually be awarded that much, or something like it, the Obama administration negotiated privately with Tehran, which agreed to settle for $1.7 billion. The $400 million stacked on pallets was the first installment.
The day it arrived, however, a great deal else was going on. January 17 was the day the international compact rolling back Iran’s nuclear program was set to take formal effect. It was also the day that Iran had, privately, agreed to release five Americans it had imprisoned on spurious charges. At the same time, the Obama administration would release seven Iranians the U.S. had held for violating sanctions—the same sanctions that had brought Iran to the negotiating table, and indeed had necessitated doing business in cash, Iran’s banks having been cut off from the international banking system.

There were a lot of moving parts and fraying nerves at the time—and the whole teetering contraption nearly came crashing down when a couple of U.S. Navy river boats strayed into Iranian waters, and were taken by the Revolutionary Guards five days before the big day. To those who follow U.S.-Iranian relations, the swiftness of the sailors’ release—the very next day—was the most impressive indication of how badly both sides wanted January 17 to come off as planned.
At least till now.
The pallets of Euros and Swiss francs are even more vivid a symbol. To Iran-watchers, they show how badly Obama’s team wanted to bolster Iran’s moderate leaders, who had promised their public that the nuclear deal would produce immediate economic improvements. It also helps to bear in mind that Iran’s theocratic government works on a patronage system. When Mahmoud Ahmadinejad was president, it was his loyalists who got the contracts to smuggle Iran’s oil past the sanctions; President Hassan Rouhani is now grappling with the fallout from paying his own people tens of thousands a month. In short, cash and a show of good will were much in demand.

Were the prisoners a factor? Even on Jan. 17, when the apparent quid pro quo was Obama’s grant of clemency to the seven Iranians, the concept of hostage-taking haunts every transaction with Iran.
The mullahs insisted that Jimmy Carter have left office before releasing the 52 original hostages, minutes after Ronald Reagan was sworn in Jan. 21, 1981. The “arms for hostages” scandal that marred Reagan’s second term brought together Iran, Central American insurgencies and U.S. prisoners held by Iranian surrogates.
Nor was President Obama the first president to look for leverage in The Hague. A flurry of claims settlements in 1989 came as President George H.W. Bush attempted to persuade Tehran to help release more American hostages, a group that was being held in Lebanon. “I’d like to get this underbrush cleaned out now,” Bush said, after the U.S. announced it was releasing $567 million in frozen assets to Tehran. “I hope,” Bush added, “they will do what they can to influence those who hold these hostages.”

At the time, a State Department official quoted in TIME acknowledged what amounted to a dance: “You want to do things that are justifiable on their own merits and defensible in terms of U.S. interests. And if Iran wants to take it as a signal, fine.” And, if not dandy, at least the way things seem to work with Iran.
 
What has Iran accomplished in the past 50 years? Has Death to America or Death to Israel helped them?

death to America? That bothers you? Just words. Iran has been a powerful middle east force.Bush taking out Iraq made them Iran more powerful. That was a big favor.
 
Back
Top