Kavanaugh and Barret are liars!

cawacko said:
From same guy who wrote the previous one. I asked if precedent and establish law are the same thing. A little inflammatory but are you buying what he's saying here?


No. It's all the same; "precedent" is just a case that is still good law ie has not yet been overturned. Every Supreme Court precedent has to be followed by every lower court and no Supreme Court precedent is binding on the Supreme Court, although they will give past opinions different levels of deference based on a variety of factors (and the draft opinion goes through this laboriously). The folks acting like Kavanaugh and Trump's other appointees "lied" because they said Roe and Casey are "precedents" or "settled law" or whatever are either ignorant or being purposely misleading. Generally if you hear something like "established law" you can just assume the person is a gasbag. Ask the folks who say that every opinion ever authored by RBG or Sotomayor, no matter how recent, is "settled law" whether they also think DC v. Heller or Citizen United v. FEC is "settled law" immune to reconsideration. You'll likely end up with a bunch of stammering and a change of subject.
Click to expand...

No, they lied. A few things.... when a law has been upheld in numerous cases, and the law has come to be relied on by society, that law is considered 'settled'. SCOTUS historically has never overturned settled law unless they believe that the decision is, as stated in this case 'egregiously decided'. This is why the opinion claims that Roe was fatally and egregiously flawed. Alito went so far as to compare it to Plessy v. Ferguson. IF they believed that was true and did not state that at their confirmation hearing, they are liars. Period, end of story.
 
Concart said:
Wonder what happened to old Darth. Given his age and his position on Covid...... well, you get the drift.
Click to expand...
I'm quite sure he's no longer with us.

Or, he finally realized that he ought to be embarrassed by his posts, and came back as a sock.

Dogshit must have gotten a whopper of a case as well, as he was absent for quite a while.
 
Althea said:
I'm quite sure he's no longer with us.

Or, he finally realized that he ought to be embarrassed by his posts, and came back as a sock.

Dogshit must have gotten a whopper of a case as well, as he was absent for quite a while.
Click to expand...

I am very interested in how the premature deaths of almost a million Americans affects the voting demographics. I suspect a disproportionate number of those who died of COVID were Republican.
 
Jarod said:
I am very interested in how the premature deaths of almost a million Americans affects the voting demographics. I suspect a disproportionate number of those who died of COVID were Republican.
Click to expand...

In a country with more than 160 million voters and a lot of those deaths in states that are heavily one party, I don't think we will see any shifts in voting demographics.

Some of the states with the highest deaths per capita -
Alabama - Trump won by 600,000 votes, 20,000 Covid deaths
Mississippi - Trump won by 250,000 votes, 12,000 Covid deaths
West Virginia - Trump won by 200,000 votes, 7,000 Covid deaths

The only reasonably purple state in the top 10 of deaths per 100,000 is Arizona.
Arizona - Biden won by 10,000 votes, 30,000 Covid deaths.
Assuming a 70/30 split by party for deaths, it still is only a 9,000 vote shift in a state where over 3 million votes were case.
 
Jarod said:
Justices Kavanaugh and Barret both testified in their nomination hearings that R. v W. is settled law and that they believed Stare Decisis prevented them from voting to overturn it...


LIARS.
Click to expand...

There is no federal abortion law, it died in the Senate.

There is no settled decision by the Supreme Court (see the recent leaked draft and segregation).

You shouild know better but ir appears that you do not.
 
Earl said:
There is no federal abortion law, it died in the Senate.

There is no settled decision by the Supreme Court (see the recent leaked draft and segregation).

You shouild know better but ir appears that you do not.
Click to expand...

Those two voted to support an opinion that would overturn R v W

There is a federal abortion bill in the Senate, but I can’t see it’s relevance to my post.
 
Jarod said:
Justices Kavanaugh and Barret both testified in their nomination hearings that R. v W. is settled law and that they believed Stare Decisis prevented them from voting to overturn it...


LIARS.
Click to expand...

SUCK THE SUCK..u stupid commie son of a slut bitch
 
cawacko said:
I'm not an attorney and don't pretend to play one but saw this posted and it makes certain sense:


"Nobody ever comments on how they’ll decide cases during nomination hearings anymore. Simply noting that something is precedent doesn’t mean they would never find reason to overturn it if it was decided wrongly."
Click to expand...

Indeed.

They never said how they would vote on Roe vs. Wade.

Jared is lying...as usual.
 
Jarod said:
Those two voted to support an opinion that would overturn R v W

There is a federal abortion bill in the Senate, but I can’t see it’s relevance to my post.
Click to expand...

As I said, there is no federal abortion law.

As I said, segregation was “settled.” Now it isn’t.

Slavery was “settled.” Now it isn’t.

There has been no final vote at the SC.
 
Jarod said:
I am very interested in how the premature deaths of almost a million Americans affects the voting demographics. I suspect a disproportionate number of those who died of COVID were Republican.
Click to expand...
One would think, but carriers infected everyone during the first wave. Later on, I'm sure you are correct. Only morons died because they attended super spreader events.
 
Earl said:
As I said, there is no federal abortion law.

As I said, segregation was “settled.” Now it isn’t.

Slavery was “settled.” Now it isn’t.

There has been no final vote at the SC.
Click to expand...

All true, so?
 
Trump's SCOTUS appointments look like they were appointed by Trump.

All three of them and he belong in the same dumpster fire.

And as long as we're burning, there are the 74,000,000 mutants that voted for him.

They're all malignant cancers on the population.
 
ExpressLane said:
And Ketanji Brown Jackson said she does not know what a woman is. Are you whining about that too Jarod. My guess they were convinced they were incorrect after they hear the argument on abortion.
Click to expand...
She did not say that, she just refused to take the bait! She’s a very smart lady and will make an excellent Supreme, one of the most qualified to sit in the bench.
 
Jarod said:
Me, really, coming from you? You promote the BIG lie.
Click to expand...



Jarod:
Kavanaugh and Barret are liars!

Justices Kavanaugh and Barret both testified in their nomination hearings that R. v W. is settled law and that they believed Stare Decisis prevented them from voting to overturn it...


LIARS.


You are the liar, they never said that.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top