Pot...kettle.
Note the title. "Obama v. BP...The Damage Beyond the Spill". They weren't trying to make him appear "thoughtful", they wanted him to look depressed and alone.
Reuters criticized The Economist for using their photographer's picture this way. But nice attempt on your part to defend shabby journalistic ethics.

Either way, it doesn't matter to me all that much other than to make it funny. I'm not criticizing anything, I am simply pointing out that I think it is humorous. Your automatic defense mode isn't helping your "Chstiefan isn't a hack" case, it just makes it more obvious and the whole thread more hilarious.