"Immigrants cause less crime, yada, yada..."

[T. A. Gardner]

Seems this isn't the case in New York City where 75% of crime in Manhattan is done by illegal aliens.

Exclusive | Migrants flooding NYC’s justice system — making up ‘75% of arrests in Midtown’ — as ‘pathetic’ sanctuary city laws handcuff cops

“The sanctuary city law is pathetic. It’s disgusting. It’s crazy,” Jim Quinn, a veteran ex prosecutor at the Queens Districts Attorney’s office, told The Post.

nypost.com

Illegal immigrants make up 75% of arrests in midtown Manhattan, say police: report

Police sources estimate that has much as 75% of arrests in Midtown Manhattan and more than 60% in Queens are of illegal immigrants, according to a report in the New York Post.

www.foxnews.com

Migrant Surge Challenges NYC’s Legal System, Accounts for Most Midtown Arrests Amid Sanctuary City Debates – PublicLawLibrary.org

Bombshell claim: Nearly 75% of arrests in Midtown are from illegal immigrants flooding the city

Illegal immigrants flooding the city are accounting for nearly 75 percent of crimes in Midtown, according to police sourc...

lawenforcementtoday.com

Legal immigrants (Hooray!) commit less crime than the general US population. Good for them! ILLEGAL ALIENS on the other hand commit far more crime. Just one more reason to DEPORT THEM ALL!

 

[T. A. Gardner]

Another day, another demolition of the Leftist narrative, and they won't even try and defend their claims.

 

[Noking]

Seems this isn't the case in New York City where 75% of crime in Manhattan is done by illegal aliens.

Exclusive | Migrants flooding NYC’s justice system — making up ‘75% of arrests in Midtown’ — as ‘pathetic’ sanctuary city laws handcuff cops

“The sanctuary city law is pathetic. It’s disgusting. It’s crazy,” Jim Quinn, a veteran ex prosecutor at the Queens Districts Attorney’s office, told The Post.

nypost.com

Illegal immigrants make up 75% of arrests in midtown Manhattan, say police: report

Police sources estimate that has much as 75% of arrests in Midtown Manhattan and more than 60% in Queens are of illegal immigrants, according to a report in the New York Post.

www.foxnews.com

Migrant Surge Challenges NYC’s Legal System, Accounts for Most Midtown Arrests Amid Sanctuary City Debates – PublicLawLibrary.org

Bombshell claim: Nearly 75% of arrests in Midtown are from illegal immigrants flooding the city

Illegal immigrants flooding the city are accounting for nearly 75 percent of crimes in Midtown, according to police sourc...

lawenforcementtoday.com

Legal immigrants (Hooray!) commit less crime than the general US population. Good for them! ILLEGAL ALIENS on the other hand commit far more crime. Just one more reason to DEPORT THEM ALL!

You should consider using credible source for you references.

 

[T. A. Gardner]

You should consider using credible source for you references.

Prove it isn't. What do you consider credible sources, some radical Leftist rag instead, like say, The Daily Beast maybe?

 

[Ross Dolan]

You should consider using credible source for you references.

Now you are being unreasonable, Noking. If people like TA used "credible sources"...they would have nothing to post.

 

[Ross Dolan]

Seems this isn't the case in New York City where 75% of crime in Manhattan is done by illegal aliens.

Exclusive | Migrants flooding NYC’s justice system — making up ‘75% of arrests in Midtown’ — as ‘pathetic’ sanctuary city laws handcuff cops

“The sanctuary city law is pathetic. It’s disgusting. It’s crazy,” Jim Quinn, a veteran ex prosecutor at the Queens Districts Attorney’s office, told The Post.

nypost.com

Illegal immigrants make up 75% of arrests in midtown Manhattan, say police: report

Police sources estimate that has much as 75% of arrests in Midtown Manhattan and more than 60% in Queens are of illegal immigrants, according to a report in the New York Post.

www.foxnews.com

Migrant Surge Challenges NYC’s Legal System, Accounts for Most Midtown Arrests Amid Sanctuary City Debates – PublicLawLibrary.org

Bombshell claim: Nearly 75% of arrests in Midtown are from illegal immigrants flooding the city

Illegal immigrants flooding the city are accounting for nearly 75 percent of crimes in Midtown, according to police sourc...

lawenforcementtoday.com

Legal immigrants (Hooray!) commit less crime than the general US population. Good for them! ILLEGAL ALIENS on the other hand commit far more crime. Just one more reason to DEPORT THEM ALL!

MIDTOWN MANHATTAN!

So this rag of a newspaper had to pick the arrest records of TWO precincts of 78 total precincts in NYC...to make a point about...what???

The north midtown precinct (the 18th) and the south midtown precinct (the 14th)...out of 78 total precincts to make what???

Wake the fuck up!

 

[T. A. Gardner]

Now you are being unreasonable, Noking. If people like TA used "credible sources"...they would have nothing to post.

Name what you are calling "credible sources."

 

[Ross Dolan]

Name what you are calling "credible sources."

Read what I just posted...and explain to me why you consider your source to be a credible source.

 

[countryboy]

You should consider using credible source for you references.

Lol. Libs use the worst sources imaginable, you haven't a leg to stand on.

 

[T. A. Gardner]

MIDTOWN MANHATTAN!

So this rag of a newspaper had to pick the arrest records of TWO precincts of 78 total precincts in NYC...to make a point about...what???

The north midtown precinct (the 18th) and the south midtown precinct (the 14th)...out of 78 total precincts to make what???

Wake the fuck up!

Trivial objections fallacy. Is the information presented in the article accurate? You are just making a Sorites fallacy here by implying you reject the data because it isn't comprehensive to all of NYC.

 

[Noking]

Prove it isn't. What do you consider credible sources, some radical Leftist rag instead, like say, The Daily Beast maybe?

Apparently you're just not capable of recognizing propaganda from news. When you read a so called article and it's leading the reader to a conclusion, then more than likely it's propaganda .

 

[Noking]

Lol. Libs use the worst sources imaginable, you haven't a leg to stand on.

This is a very feeble rebuttal.

 

[countryboy]

This is a very feeble rebuttal.

In other words, absolutely true and factual.

 

[Noking]

In other words, absolutely true and factual.

It absolutely true in your sick and demented mind.

 

[Ross Dolan]

Trivial objections fallacy. Is the information presented in the article accurate? You are just making a Sorites fallacy here by implying you reject the data because it isn't comprehensive to all of NYC.

Stop with the intellectual bullshit.

It seems you are not from this area. You seems not to know the New York Post.

Am I correct?

 

[Jake Starkey]

nypost and fox.com? There is no evidence that immigrants in NYC commit more crime than native‑born residents overall. Your search results show two different things: (1) a subset of recent asylum‑seekers involved in arrests , and (2) crime increases in immigrant neighborhoods, which does not mean immigrants are the offenders .The broader research consensus (NYU, CUNY, national criminology studies) consistently finds immigrants commit less crime than native‑born Americans, including in NYC. .yahoo.com/news/shocking-data-detail-nyc-illegal-185246378.html?utm_source=copilot.com (and) www.kclu.org/2025-04-28/non-major-crime-rate-at-a-20-year-high-in-several-nyc-immigrant-neighborhoods-data-shows?utm_source=copilot.com

A. NYPD data on ​

• 3,219 migrants in shelters were arrested 4,884 times between Jan 2023–Oct 2024.
• This represents about 4% of the 200,000+ asylum seekers who arrived.
• Most charges were petit larceny, assault, and drug offenses.

What this means: A small subset of recent arrivals committed crimes — but this does not reflect immigrants as a whole. www.yahoo.com/news/shocking-data-detail-nyc-illegal-185246378.html?utm_source=copilot.com

Reconciling the Headlines With the Data​

Claim	What the Data Actually Shows
“Migrants are causing crime in NYC”	A small subset of recent asylum seekers committed crimes; this does not reflect immigrants overall.
“Crime is rising in immigrant neighborhoods”	True in some areas — but offenders are not necessarily immigrants.
“Immigrants commit less crime”	Supported by decades of NYC and national research.

5. Bottom Line​

Yes — the statement “immigrants cause less crime in NYC” is broadly true when referring to immigrants as a whole. Your search results highlight specific subgroups and neighborhood trends, but they do not contradict the long‑standing finding that immigrants overall are less likely to commit crime than native‑born residents.

 

[countryboy]

It absolutely true in your sick and demented mind.

You're projecting again. It's all you people have.

 

[Nomad]

Seems this isn't the case in New York City where 75% of crime in Manhattan is done by illegal aliens.

Legal immigrants (Hooray!) commit less crime than the general US population. Good for them! ILLEGAL ALIENS on the other hand commit far more crime. Just one more reason to DEPORT THEM ALL!

So, who do you mean by "THEM ALL"?

 

[Jake Starkey]

Stop with the intellectual bullshit.

It seems you are not from this area. You seem not to know the New York Post.

Am I correct?

Another poser is our little buddy.

 

[Diogenes]

Isn't refuting a source instead of the data a fallacious argument?