Fossil Ida: extraordinary find is 'missing link' in human evolution

Socrtease

Verified User
http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/2009/may/19/ida-fossil-missing-link

Scientists have discovered an exquisitely preserved ancient primate fossil that they believe forms a crucial "missing link" between our own evolutionary branch of life and the rest of the animal kingdom.

The 47m-year-old primate – named Ida – has been hailed as the fossil equivalent of a "Rosetta Stone" for understanding the critical early stages of primate evolution.

The top-level international research team, who have studied her in secret for the past two years, believe she is the most complete and best preserved primate fossil ever uncovered. The skeleton is 95% complete and thanks to the unique location where she died, it is possible to see individual hairs covering her body and even the make-up of her final meal – a last vegetarian snack.

Ida-the-missing-link-prim-001.jpg


"This little creature is going to show us our connection with the rest of all the mammals; with cows and sheep, and elephants and anteaters," said Sir David Attenborough who is narrating a BBC documentary on the find. "The more you look at Ida, the more you can see, as it were, the primate in embryo."

"This will be the one pictured in the textbooks for the next hundred years," said Dr Jørn Hurum, the palaeontologist from Oslo University's Natural History Museum who assembled the scientific team to study the fossil. "It tells a part of our evolution that's been hidden so far. It's been hidden because the only [other] specimens are so incomplete and so broken there's nothing almost to study." The fossil has been formally named Darwinius masillae in honour of Darwin's 200th birthday year.

It has been shipped across the Atlantic for an unveiling ceremony hosted by the mayor of New York Michael Bloomberg today. There is even talk of Ida being the first non-living thing to feature on the front cover of People magazine.

She will then be transported back to Oslo, via a brief stop at the Natural History Museum in London on Tuesday, 26 May, when Attenborough will host a press conference.

Ida was originally discovered by an amateur fossil hunter in the summer of 1983 at Messel pit, a world renowned fossil site near Darmstadt in Germany. He kept it under wraps for over 20 years before deciding to sell it via a German fossil dealer called Thomas Perner. It was Perner who approached Hurum two years ago.

"My heart started beating extremely fast," said Hurum, "I knew that the dealer had a world sensation in his hands. I could not sleep for 2 nights. I was just thinking about how to get this to an official museum so that it could be described and published for science." Hurum would not reveal what the university museum paid for the fossil, but the original asking price was $1m. He did not see the fossil before buying it – just three photographs, representing a huge gamble.

But it appears to have paid off. "You need an icon or two in a museum to drag people in," said Hurum, "this is our Mona Lisa and it will be our Mona Lisa for the next 100 years."

Hurum chose Ida's nickname because the diminutive creature is at the equivalent stage of development as his six-year-old daughter. Hurum said Ida is very excited about her namesake. "She says, 'there are two Idas now, there's me I'm living and then there's the dead one.'"

"It's caught at a really very interesting moment [in the animal's life] when it fortunately has all its baby teeth and is in the process of forming all its permanent teeth," said Dr Holly Smith, an expert in primate development at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor, who was part of the team. "So you have more information in it than almost any fossil you could think of."

The fossil's amazing preservation means that the scientific team has managed to glean a huge amount of information from it, although this required new X-ray techniques that had not previously been applied to any other specimens.

The researchers believe it comes from the time when the primate lineage, that diversified into monkeys, apes and ultimately humans, split from a separate group that went on to become lemurs and other less well known species.

Crucially though, Ida is not on the lemur line because she lacks two key characteristics shared by lemurs – a grooming claw on her second toe and a fused set of teeth called a tooth comb. Also, a bone in her ankle called the talus is shaped like members of our branch of the primates. So the researchers believe she may be on our evolutionary line dating from just after the split with the lemurs.

According to the team's published description of the skeleton in the journal PLoS ONE, Ida was 53cm long and a juvenile around six to nine months old. The team can be sure Ida is a girl because she does not have a penis bone.

"She was at this vulnerable age where you are no longer right with your mother," said Smith, "Just as you leave weaning you are not full grown, but you are on your own."

The unprecedented preservation of Ida meant working out how she died was more like a modern day crime scene investigation than the informed guess-work that palaeontologists usually make do with. The team noticed that she had a broken wrist that had begun to partially heal. The injury did not kill her, but they speculate that it contributed to her premature demise.

"It might be that her mother dropped her once or that she fell down from a tree earlier in her life," Smith said. She survived the accident, but her climbing abilities would have been impaired. Unable to drink from water trapped by tree leaves, she would have had to venture down to the lake to drink. This would have proved to be a fateful decision.

The huge range of magnificently preserved fossils at Messel suggest that the volcanic lake was a death trap. Scientists believe that it sporadically let forth giant belches of poisonous volcanic gases that would have immediately suffocated anything in, around and even over the water. Ida would then have fallen into the water and been preserved in the sediment deep at the bottom.

• Atlantic productions' programme, Uncovering Our Earliest Ancestor: The Link, will be broadcast in the UK on Tuesday, 26 May at 9pm on BBC1. Colin Tudge's book, The Link, is published on 20 May by Little Brown.
 
http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/2009/may/19/ida-fossil-missing-link

Scientists have discovered an exquisitely preserved ancient primate fossil that they believe forms a crucial "missing link" between our own evolutionary branch of life and the rest of the animal kingdom.

The 47m-year-old primate – named Ida – has been hailed as the fossil equivalent of a "Rosetta Stone" for understanding the critical early stages of primate evolution.

The top-level international research team, who have studied her in secret for the past two years, believe she is the most complete and best preserved primate fossil ever uncovered. The skeleton is 95% complete and thanks to the unique location where she died, it is possible to see individual hairs covering her body and even the make-up of her final meal – a last vegetarian snack.

Ida-the-missing-link-prim-001.jpg


"This little creature is going to show us our connection with the rest of all the mammals; with cows and sheep, and elephants and anteaters," said Sir David Attenborough who is narrating a BBC documentary on the find. "The more you look at Ida, the more you can see, as it were, the primate in embryo."

"This will be the one pictured in the textbooks for the next hundred years," said Dr Jørn Hurum, the palaeontologist from Oslo University's Natural History Museum who assembled the scientific team to study the fossil. "It tells a part of our evolution that's been hidden so far. It's been hidden because the only [other] specimens are so incomplete and so broken there's nothing almost to study." The fossil has been formally named Darwinius masillae in honour of Darwin's 200th birthday year.

It has been shipped across the Atlantic for an unveiling ceremony hosted by the mayor of New York Michael Bloomberg today. There is even talk of Ida being the first non-living thing to feature on the front cover of People magazine.

She will then be transported back to Oslo, via a brief stop at the Natural History Museum in London on Tuesday, 26 May, when Attenborough will host a press conference.

Ida was originally discovered by an amateur fossil hunter in the summer of 1983 at Messel pit, a world renowned fossil site near Darmstadt in Germany. He kept it under wraps for over 20 years before deciding to sell it via a German fossil dealer called Thomas Perner. It was Perner who approached Hurum two years ago.

"My heart started beating extremely fast," said Hurum, "I knew that the dealer had a world sensation in his hands. I could not sleep for 2 nights. I was just thinking about how to get this to an official museum so that it could be described and published for science." Hurum would not reveal what the university museum paid for the fossil, but the original asking price was $1m. He did not see the fossil before buying it – just three photographs, representing a huge gamble.

But it appears to have paid off. "You need an icon or two in a museum to drag people in," said Hurum, "this is our Mona Lisa and it will be our Mona Lisa for the next 100 years."

Hurum chose Ida's nickname because the diminutive creature is at the equivalent stage of development as his six-year-old daughter. Hurum said Ida is very excited about her namesake. "She says, 'there are two Idas now, there's me I'm living and then there's the dead one.'"

"It's caught at a really very interesting moment [in the animal's life] when it fortunately has all its baby teeth and is in the process of forming all its permanent teeth," said Dr Holly Smith, an expert in primate development at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor, who was part of the team. "So you have more information in it than almost any fossil you could think of."

The fossil's amazing preservation means that the scientific team has managed to glean a huge amount of information from it, although this required new X-ray techniques that had not previously been applied to any other specimens.

The researchers believe it comes from the time when the primate lineage, that diversified into monkeys, apes and ultimately humans, split from a separate group that went on to become lemurs and other less well known species.

Crucially though, Ida is not on the lemur line because she lacks two key characteristics shared by lemurs – a grooming claw on her second toe and a fused set of teeth called a tooth comb. Also, a bone in her ankle called the talus is shaped like members of our branch of the primates. So the researchers believe she may be on our evolutionary line dating from just after the split with the lemurs.

According to the team's published description of the skeleton in the journal PLoS ONE, Ida was 53cm long and a juvenile around six to nine months old. The team can be sure Ida is a girl because she does not have a penis bone.

"She was at this vulnerable age where you are no longer right with your mother," said Smith, "Just as you leave weaning you are not full grown, but you are on your own."

The unprecedented preservation of Ida meant working out how she died was more like a modern day crime scene investigation than the informed guess-work that palaeontologists usually make do with. The team noticed that she had a broken wrist that had begun to partially heal. The injury did not kill her, but they speculate that it contributed to her premature demise.

"It might be that her mother dropped her once or that she fell down from a tree earlier in her life," Smith said. She survived the accident, but her climbing abilities would have been impaired. Unable to drink from water trapped by tree leaves, she would have had to venture down to the lake to drink. This would have proved to be a fateful decision.

The huge range of magnificently preserved fossils at Messel suggest that the volcanic lake was a death trap. Scientists believe that it sporadically let forth giant belches of poisonous volcanic gases that would have immediately suffocated anything in, around and even over the water. Ida would then have fallen into the water and been preserved in the sediment deep at the bottom.

• Atlantic productions' programme, Uncovering Our Earliest Ancestor: The Link, will be broadcast in the UK on Tuesday, 26 May at 9pm on BBC1. Colin Tudge's book, The Link, is published on 20 May by Little Brown.

But no matter how much evidence comes forth, Creationist will just deny that any evolution took place on planet Earth....how they explain why the Bible doesn't account for all those fossils that prove the existence of prehistoric life is truly comical.
 

Thinking like a creationist, IB1. Not closing a gap, opening up two more. They'll never be happy.

It's not like missing link is the biggest evidence for evolution anyway. Darwin believed it would be, but he was wrong, and later scientists improved upon the theory. That's how science works. Creationists can't think like that. Their dogma, religion, doesn't allow for change as new evidence comes in. The bible is right period and that's it. They can't see that their supposed argument against evolution (that much of what he said has fallen out of favor) is actually an argument for science, because they are stuck in the religious mindset.

So, this missing link fossil proves nothing to them, because there aren't enough. And there never will be enough.
 
Thinking like a creationist, IB1. Not closing a gap, opening up two more. They'll never be happy.

It's not like missing link is the biggest evidence for evolution anyway. Darwin believed it would be, but he was wrong, and later scientists improved upon the theory. That's how science works. Creationists can't think like that. Their dogma, religion, doesn't allow for change as new evidence comes in. The bible is right period and that's it. They can't see that their supposed argument against evolution (that much of what he said has fallen out of favor) is actually an argument for science, because they are stuck in the religious mindset.

So, this missing link fossil proves nothing to them, because there aren't enough. And there never will be enough.

Well put.
 
But no matter how much evidence comes forth, Creationist will just deny that any evolution took place on planet Earth....how they explain why the Bible doesn't account for all those fossils that prove the existence of prehistoric life is truly comical.

Yes, we are aware of that. Each time new evidence is gained supporting evolution they just raise the bar of proof higher.
 
Wow! Fantastic. I don't understand how somebody could just sit on this for two decades; guess they really didn't realize what they had. Absolutely priceless!
 
Wow! Fantastic. I don't understand how somebody could just sit on this for two decades; guess they really didn't realize what they had. Absolutely priceless!

Well I dunno about that. I'd like to see some more information. How is this a transitional species? What anatomical features indicate homological and phylogenic changes that would classify this as transitional?

That aside, it's one of the most amazing fossil specimens I've ever seen. The level of completeness and preservation is amazing.
 
Well I dunno about that. I'd like to see some more information. How is this a transformational species? What anatomical features indicate homological and phylogenic changes that would classify this as transitional?

That aside, it's one of the most amazing fossil specimens I've ever seen. The level of completeness and preservation is amazing.

If this has been published in Nature, that would probably be the best place to look. This Guardian UK article was written for public consumption, and in terms of the details that you and I would want to know, it would be unsatisfactory. I should go back to see if they bothered to give a reference (too often they don't!).
 
Not being a chap who is used to scrabbling around on one's hands and knees in search of some dirty bone action, i don't know if this skellington thing will explain how we evolved from lemur-like things or not.

However, whoever is doing the marketing for it is well on top of his/her game. A website, a television documentary and a book all unveiled at the same time as the fossil itself. And there's even a little picture of it on the Google home page today (in the UK anyway). Let's see whether it's the genuine article or, as some bone spod from the Carnegie Museum said last night, a triumph of marketing over substance.
 
God put the fossil there to cover up his work.
More likely God's teacher asked him to "show" his work so he kind of sloppily added a few of these things around to give the impression that he made an effort in that direction. In some cases he sloppily erased it, but since he got most of the answers right the teacher forgave him and gave him a passing grade anyway. Probably something like, "That's pretty good!"

Then God said, "It is good." Then his mom came to pick him up from school, hair in curlers... he was sooooo embarrassed!
 
Not being a chap who is used to scrabbling around on one's hands and knees in search of some dirty bone action, i don't know if this skellington thing will explain how we evolved from lemur-like things or not.

However, whoever is doing the marketing for it is well on top of his/her game. A website, a television documentary and a book all unveiled at the same time as the fossil itself. And there's even a little picture of it on the Google home page today (in the UK anyway). Let's see whether it's the genuine article or, as some bone spod from the Carnegie Museum said last night, a triumph of marketing over substance.
The Brit fears another "Piltdown Man"...

:D
 
Not being a chap who is used to scrabbling around on one's hands and knees in search of some dirty bone action, i don't know if this skellington thing will explain how we evolved from lemur-like things or not.

However, whoever is doing the marketing for it is well on top of his/her game. A website, a television documentary and a book all unveiled at the same time as the fossil itself. And there's even a little picture of it on the Google home page today (in the UK anyway). Let's see whether it's the genuine article or, as some bone spod from the Carnegie Museum said last night, a triumph of marketing over substance.

Evolutionary implications aside, this fossil is worthy of such attention as this is one of the best examples of fossil perservation I've ever seen. It's just nothing short of spectacular.
 
The Brit fears another "Piltdown Man"...

:D

Part of me hopes it is a big old fraud.

I'm not sure how i'm going to cope once it is revealed that the man i called Granddad was, in actual fact, nothing but a rather cunning saucer-eyed lemur.
 
Back
Top