Huh. Well, I live with a man who is very substantively different than superfreak. I kid around with SF a lot, and I do like him when all is said and done, and maybe I have flirted with him once in a while, but I would not date him. Too many built-in deal breakers. I don't date Republicans and haven't in years. I have a magnet on my refrigerator "Sorry darling, I just can't love a republican". I'd hang out with him and I'm sure have some laughs but that's it.
Men I would go on a date with from JPP if I were single (and I am not), and they were single too:
Ornot from years ago.
DH
At one time Onceler, but he's been knocked off the list
Rune
Probably you, you seem like fun
I think age appropriateness pretty much rules out anyone else who isn't already ruled out for other reasons. If I were in my 20's the list would be different I'm sure.
Can't really think of anyone else honestly, I may have forgotten someone though.