"Freedom of property" = fascism.
You prove too much. 1/4 is just an arbitrary number you picked out of thin air. There's no reason it can't be 1/2, 1/3, or 9/10. If you are going to argue that some number you arbitrarily picked out of thin air is immoral simply because it is immoral and does not congrue with the natural morality of the universe for reasons I can't understand, then OK. You are a Christian and I am sure you are used to making arguments like this. But don't act like your argument has any real validity.
What you are getting into is that taxation is theft, you are getting into anarchism, and I'm sorry, I'm unwilling to take an anarchist seriously.
Actually, if we are going to go with my religious background, then I will be happy to oblige. I am a Catholic, and I can tell you this:
America has very little in common with the historic values of my faith
-Except for the early development of English Common Law, no where else on Earth can the Catholic Church be seen to have promoted democracy or limited government, or constitutionalism.
-America was founded largely by people who were virulently anti-Catholic.
-Even my hero, John Adams, was strongly prejudiced growing up and I got to read some very juicy writings of his. He later came to view Catholicism with warm regards and even attended Masses in Pennsylvania, the only place aside from Rhode Island where it was tolerated.
-The only semi-prominent Founding Father who was Catholic was John Carroll.
-Most ethnic minorities in America were historically targeted for coming from Catholic countries (Irish, Slavs, Germans, etc.).
Historically, Catholics came to this country, and then proceeded to attack its principles by voting Democrat. It has always been fiscally liberal because the tyranny of government is viewed in Catholic circles as compassionate and charitable.
As a fully assimilated Catholic/European who has no recollection of persecution, I have come to believe in the values of the American experiment, but it is in spite of what the Church has usually done in this country, which is to blindly follow liberals in destroying this country and its principles. My concept of 1/4 is the idea that anything more than 25% is clearly punative, and therefore against the right of property.