Can anyone make a cogent case for how birthright citizenship is good for America?

[EdwinA]

The more Americans born in the US the more workers there will be in 18 years making contributions to Social Security which will help keep it solvent.

Rubbish. They want to outsource jobs that produce real gains, then they can tax the imports as if those workers were still employed here. Pretty simple fix, only Democrats are just big shills for big corps, not much different than the GOP shills, so of course we get stuff like your ignorant stupid shit that does nothing.

The peanut Gallery can amuse themselves checking out the labor stats. Corps have down-sized their white collar forces by over 5%, and less than 15% of College STEM grads actually get a job in a tech field. Those 'skilled labor shortages' are a hoax, and have been since the 1980's. And we know why construction companies have to rely on criminal illegal aliens, so their 'shortages' are self-inflicted as well, so fuck all of them. It will take years to balance out self-inflicted problems caused over decades of labor racketeering.

All you whiney burb brats raised to expect instant gratification should just kill yourselves now and stop annoying the adults.

 

[IBDaMann]

You would be correct in that assessment. So clarify your post.

Which post? All of my posts are clear. It would be best if you were to pinpoint where you are experiencing difficulty and need further assistance.

 

[IBDaMann]

Biden deported more than Trump.

Here is where we must perform a "net flow" analysis. Biden allowed entry to tens of millions more illegals than he deported.

 

[AProudLefty]

Here is where we must perform a "net flow" analysis. Biden allowed entry to tens of millions more illegals than he deported.

No such analysis.

 

[AProudLefty]

Which post? All of my posts are clear. It would be best if you were to pinpoint where you are experiencing difficulty and need further assistance.

I see that you had difficulty in determining which post I was referring to.

Here, my child, is your post.

Now you're pivoting. You waited until the 3rd post this time, which might be a new record for you.

 

[Trumpet]

Here is where we must perform a "net flow" analysis. Biden allowed entry to tens of millions more illegals than he deported.

did Crazy Trump tell you that?????

 

[Poor Richard Saunders]

Rubbish. They want to outsource jobs that produce real gains, then they can tax the imports as if those workers were still employed here. Pretty simple fix, only Democrats are just big shills for big corps, not much different than the GOP shills, so of course we get stuff like your ignorant stupid shit that does nothing.

The peanut Gallery can amuse themselves checking out the labor stats. Corps have down-sized their white collar forces by over 5%, and less than 15% of College STEM grads actually get a job in a tech field. Those 'skilled labor shortages' are a hoax, and have been since the 1980's. And we know why construction companies have to rely on criminal illegal aliens, so their 'shortages' are self-inflicted as well, so fuck all of them. It will take years to balance out self-inflicted problems caused over decades of labor racketeering.

All you whiney burb brats raised to expect instant gratification should just kill yourselves now and stop annoying the adults.

You are consistent in your inability to understand anything other than your narrow world view.

 

[IBDaMann]

No such analysis.

Not that you've yet made, no.

 

[AProudLefty]

Not that you've yet made, no.

Very childish.

 

[IBDaMann]

I see that you had difficulty in determining which post I was referring to.

I can't read your mind.

 

[IBDaMann]

I see that you had difficulty in determining which post I was referring to.

Here, my child, is your post.

You failed to pinpoint where you are experiencing difficulty and where you need further assistance.

 

[IBDaMann]

did Crazy Trump tell you that?????

Trump recommends using only one question mark at a time. Teenage girls who gossip at the mall, however, recommend using question marks in groups of five.

 

[Yakuda]

Nope. That sounds like insurance. The question is will people get more out when adjusted for inflation? Have you done the math or are you relying on others without checking if they are telling you the truth?

Did you forget you said you wished you would have been able to opt out of SS and invest that money. I am pointing out you are easily duped and likely would have lost it all if you had done so since you fall for false information. Lucky for you there is SS.

Not insurance at all

The weak minded like people like yourself do need a mommy govt to take care of you.

 

[Dutch Uncle]

Trump recommends using only one question mark at a time. Teenage girls who gossip at the mall, however, recommend using question marks in groups of five.

Random words. No apparent coherency.

 

[Poor Richard Saunders]

Here is where we must perform a "net flow" analysis. Biden allowed entry to tens of millions more illegals than he deported.

Net flow analysis?
Jan 1, 2021 - June 1, 2024
Total encounters - 10.079 million
Total expulsions at the border - 2.561 million
Total ruled inadmissible and removed - 2.867 million

Total apprehended and not immediately removed - 4.651 million
Total removed at the border 5.428 million

Data can be downloaded from here using "Get the data" link -

Statistics on unauthorized US immigration and US border crossings by year | USAFacts

The US has reported nearly 11 million unauthorized border encounters between October 2019 and June 2024.

usafacts.org

4.65 million is not tens of millions

ICE estimates they encountered 78% of those trying to cross the border. That leaves about 3 million that may have made it across without being apprehended by ICE.

7.65 million is not tens of millions. Even if Biden deported zero persons, it would be impossible for him to have allowed entry to tens of millions.

 

[AProudLefty]

You failed to pinpoint where you are experiencing difficulty and where you need further assistance.

As I thought. Dismissed.

 

[AProudLefty]

I can't read your mind.

You can read the quoted parts.

 

[Poor Richard Saunders]

Not insurance at all

Insurance - The money that is collected from premiums is paid out to other people.
Social Security - The money that is collected from taxes is paid out to other people.

The weak minded like people like yourself do need a mommy govt to take care of you.

I always find statements like that to be humorous. They tend to reveal more about the person making them than about the person they are trying to accuse of something.

 

[Nordberg]

So right wing logic is that if you're born in America, you are not a citizen of America. Where would you be a citizen? Are you a child without a nation? Everyone's parents came from somewhere else. I guess we are birthing children without a country.
Rightys believe the crazy shit they are suggestting will not be used on them.

 

[zymurgy]

The more Americans born in the US the more workers there will be in 18 years making contributions to Social Security which will help keep it solvent.

^when mouth breathers get to make policy

we have no shortage of people - law abiding people with skills - that are willing to come here legally, can fill the shortage via legal immigration

Your solution is much like saying rape should be legal since we need to have babies born