Birthright Citizenship is Secure

IBDaMann

IBDaMann

Well-known member
It was the only possible outcome.

WASHINGTON — A federal appeals court in San Francisco ruled Wednesday that President Donald Trump's order seeking to end birthright citizenship is unconstitutional, affirming a lower-court decision that blocked its enforcement nationwide.

Trump's executive order is unconstitutional
 
IBDaMann said:
Your question is unclear. What is the "that" specifically of which you are asking if I am glad?
Click to expand...
Aren't you glad that the court ruled that Crazy Trump's order to end birthright citizenship is unconstitutional.
 
Trumpet said:
Aren't you glad that the court ruled that Crazy Trump's order to end birthright citizenship is unconstitutional.
Click to expand...
I am glad that an unconstitutional order was decided to be unconstitutional. I am happy that the decision was the correct one.
 
Teflon Don said:
I guess it is settled then. They are the final day right?
Click to expand...
The point is that the issue had already been decided by 1) first, the founders and 2) second, the Supreme Court. Now, there is only one possilbe decision that any court can make. Precedent and the Constitution make this issue academic. When it is eventually considered by the Supreme Court, accept every fool's bet that there will somehow be a different decision.
 
IBDaMann said:
It was the only possible outcome.

WASHINGTON — A federal appeals court in San Francisco ruled Wednesday that President Donald Trump's order seeking to end birthright citizenship is unconstitutional, affirming a lower-court decision that blocked its enforcement nationwide.

Trump's executive order is unconstitutional
Click to expand...
Neither of these courts have nationwide jurisdiction, and cannot affect anything but the plaintiff and defendant involved. No court has the authority to write law. No court has the authority to change the Constitution.
 
Into the Night said:
Neither of these courts have nationwide jurisdiction, and cannot affect anything but the plaintiff and defendant involved. No court has the authority to write law. No court has the authority to change the Constitution.
Click to expand...
The point here is that the decision rendered is the only possible decision. When the issue goes to SCOTUS, they will only be able to declare that infringing on the inalienable right of US citizenship by birth, even on said right of children of illegal immigrants, is unconstitutional.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top