Are Confederate soldiers considered US vets?

He can't have it both ways!! If the secession was illegal, as he believes, then they never ceased to be US citizens and were entitled to benefits and pensions.

No, I cannot. Which is why I don't believe that the secession was illegal. That being said, even if we hold to the prevailing opinion, they still were not fighting under the US flag, and, as a rebellion, they would still not be viewed as US veterans, unless they had previously been in service (because no one was ever prosecuted for their crimes).
 
No, I cannot. Which is why I don't believe that the secession was illegal. That being said, even if we hold to the prevailing opinion, they still were not fighting under the US flag, and, as a rebellion, they would still not be viewed as US veterans, unless they had previously been in service (because no one was ever prosecuted for their crimes).
Well your precious Congress has decided that is not the case, don't you believe in Democracy?
 
Well, now that we are finally seeing a movement to stop honoring the traitors, perhaps it will lead to Congress correcting itself in the future.
nice dodge..not that i expect an honest response.
You support tearing down memorials of US vets. Just own it
 
Anyway, yeah the loser traitors became Veterans in the US by law. It's frickin' weird.

The southern confederacy has become the american version of Nazi Germany.

You leftists think you can control the atmosphere and create utopia on earth through government.

This is why all of you have to be defeated and politically exterminated as much as possible. You are all hedonists and believe in the Marxist venue of ends justifies means including using violence.
 
nice dodge..not that i expect an honest response.
You support tearing down memorials of US vets. Just own it

I support tearing down the monuments of foreign nationals that were responsible for the deaths of over 400k American lives. The motherfuckers all fought under this piece of shit flag:

Flag_of_the_Confederate_States_of_America_%281865%29.svg
 
The southern confederacy has become the american version of Nazi Germany.

You leftists think you can control the atmosphere and create utopia on earth through government.

This is why all of you have to be defeated and politically exterminated as much as possible. You are all hedonists and believe in the Marxist venue of ends justifies means including using violence.

It didn't become the American version of Nazi Germany; it was the American version of Nazi Germany.

It was the south that attempted to create utopia on earth through government, when it seceded and established a new constitution, based upon the secessionist principle of a racially ordered society.
 
I support tearing down the monuments of foreign nationals that were responsible for the deaths of over 400k American lives. The motherfuckers all fought under this piece of shit flag:

Flag_of_the_Confederate_States_of_America_%281865%29.svg
They were Americans who had their homes invaded by the armies of a tyrant named Lincoln.

You're a whiny, gutless fucking bitch that couldn't carry the jockstrap of any man who wore the blue or gray.
 
No, I cannot. Which is why I don't believe that the secession was illegal. That being said, even if we hold to the prevailing opinion, they still were not fighting under the US flag, and, as a rebellion, they would still not be viewed as US veterans, unless they had previously been in service (because no one was ever prosecuted for their crimes).

Wrong! They did fight under the US flag .. the old flag of the federal republic and not your flag of centralized authority and empire!

They weren't prosecuted because the fed had no case against them that could hold up in a US court of law. The fed needed a kangaroo court to convict them so they were held as political prisoners until hostilities ceased resulting in the deaths of over a million people and millions of dollars in private property damage.
 
Wrong! They did fight under the US flag .. the old flag of the federal republic and not your flag of centralized authority and empire!

They weren't prosecuted because the fed had no case against them that could hold up in a US court of law. The fed needed a kangaroo court to convict them so they were held as political prisoners until hostilities ceased resulting in the deaths of over a million people and millions of dollars in private property damage.

This is not a US flag:

Flag_of_the_Confederate_States_of_America_%281865%29.svg
 
I'm guessing you never served.
I am quite sure you have never served.

Otherwise you would respect the service of all.

You do realize we have Nazis buried in our National Cemeteries? You would know this had you served.

Any claims you make of serving are stolen valor.
 
I am quite sure you have never served.

Otherwise you would respect the service of all.

You do realize we have Nazis buried in our National Cemeteries? You would know this had you served.

Any claims you make of serving are stolen valor.
I'm sure you're wrong, he serves now, honorably!
 
Back
Top