7 to 1 scotus says no to abortion restrictions
- Thread starter evince
- Start date
Read Row v. Wade, its a great lesson in balance of those two rights.
canceled.2021.1
#AMERICAISDEAD
52% of planned parenthood operating revenue comes from killing babies
SmarterthanYou
rebel
restricting and reducing one right to provide for a limited right in another arena is hardly a balance between two rights. compromise does nothing but reduce an individuals freedom and places them further under governmental power.
SmarterthanYou
rebel
fixed that for you
False
The unenumerated right to basic freedom from unreasonable government intrusion into our personal medical decisions is not a limited right and is as important as the Governments legal authority to provide for the health and welfare of the people.
Its a balance between a right of the people to be free and a duty of the government to provide for health and safety.
SmarterthanYou
rebel
this is absolutely impossible, based purely upon your stance of 'no right is absolute'. so maybe you should rethink your view on constitutional rights.
canceled.2021.1
#AMERICAISDEAD
Prove it is false. I proved it is correct in APP using Planned Parenthoods own annual report. So maybe you can prove otherwise?
I will understand if you can't.
Where did you prove this?
I see your point. Its absolute in that it is a right, it is only limited when it conflicts with another absolute right.
I know that sounds like it is a fallacy because neither is absolute if its limited. The limits are a fiction the Courts create when confronted with the conflict of absolutes, because there is no other way to deal with such a situation.
canceled.2021.1
#AMERICAISDEAD
Can't you read? I told you already. Some lawyer
SmarterthanYou
rebel
you have repeatedly said that NO RIGHT IS ABSOLUTE! now, you're just tap dancing around your own trap of words. how can 'limits' be fiction if they are enforced upon individuals who are exercising said rights? how can absolutes conflict with other absolutes?
If I have an absolute right to freedom from government intervention in my health care choices, and my fetus has an absolute right to life, and I want an abortion.... don't those rights collide?
SmarterthanYou
rebel
you're making an argument that doesn't exist with me. try something different, like a right that says 'shall not be infringed'
canceled.2021.1
#AMERICAISDEAD
Except it has been long established that you don't have an absolute right to freedom from government intervention in your healthcare choices does it? Guess what? If you are Medicaid, you don't get to have you choice. You get what the government pays for. You aren't allowed to sell a kidney for profit. That is a healthcare choice with your body and you aren't allowed to make it. The government forces you to wear a helmet to protect your health.
Our government was designed to protect "life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness". Life being the critical component.
canceled.2021.1
#AMERICAISDEAD
You are creating straw man arguments. Nobody has an absolute right to practice your religion. Why do you make shit up?