I told you sycophants the constitution was clear!

[FastLane]

They did not say that indians born off the reservation are not citizens, they did not rule on that issue.

Have you read the decision?

They said Indians owed their allegiance to another sovereign power. Even today where an Indian is born has no Bering on his membership of his tribe. So it did not make any difference where a member of the Winnebago tribe was born he was still a member of the Winnebago tribe. The same is true for Apaches Cherokees etc.

How do you justify Kim Wong?

His parents were legal permanent residents and as such were under jurisdiction of the US . The Wong Ark decision even pointed out his parents permanent domicile as the reason for his citizenship. Illegal aliens are subject to immediate removal by deportation so they don't have permanent domicile..

 

[CBHype]

Yes we know you hate anyone who values love over your best girl hate

She loves you huh

If only you could realize what a dip shit you look like to the mostly decent people on this planet

But your fucking broken

So in your tiny brain prison you will stay

Snarling at everyone who passes by

You are truly ill.

 

[Libhater]

Trump's lawyer Sauer has a horrible voice. I hate listening to him talk. He also has no reasonable arguments. He is foundering and grasping for hour after hour.

Would you feel better listening to word salad kamala giggling?

 

[evince]

You are truly ill.

That one is really sloppy

You must be all worn out from defending the indefensible for so many years

 

[CBHype]

That one is really sloppy

You must be all worn out from defending the indefensible for so many years

You're projecting again.

 

[evince]

You're projecting again.

This isn’t a human

 

[Jarod]

They said Indians owed their allegiance to another sovereign power. Even today where an Indian is born has no Bering on his membership of his tribe. So it did not make any difference where a member of the Winnebago tribe was born he was still a member of the Winnebago tribe. The same is true for Apaches Cherokees etc.

His parents were legal permanent residents and as such were under jurisdiction of the US . The Wong Ark decision even pointed out his parents permanent domicile as the reason for his citizenship. Illegal aliens are subject to immediate removal by deportation so they don't have permanent domicile..

Why does not being here legally affect the government’s jurisdiction? How could they be removed if they aren’t under the government’s jurisdiction?

 

[Lionfish]

You should take a literacy course.

Need a bridge loan to buy Easter eggs for your family?

 

[Tbird19482]

And yet federal marshals can go on reservations and enforce federal laws. Indians are subject to federal laws but not state laws.

A person here illegally cannot vote and cannot be drafted.

Native Americans don't even own the reservation lands. The Federal government owns the land . While tribes possess beneficial interest and the federal government acts as trustee, meaning land-use decisions often require approval from the Secretary of the Interior.

I believe you are wrong on this point.
At least with the Seneca Nation , they are a independent nation and have duel citizenship.
They own their land and only women can own it, men can not own land on the Rez , Men can get life use but when they die it has to go back to a woman .
It is their belief that the blood line comes from the women not men like we do.

 

[Into the Night]

Polly is a sewer bound cracker

Your brain wiring has too few pathways

Yes we know you hate anyone who values love over your best girl hate

She loves you huh

If only you could realize what a dip shit you look like to the mostly decent people on this planet

But your fucking broken

So in your tiny brain prison you will stay

Snarling at everyone who passes by

Stooge has no argument or counter-argument. Just useless insults.

Mantras 1a. Lame.

 

[Into the Night]

How does being here legally or not affect what jurisdiction they are subject to?

RQAA. Go back and read it. Stop asking the same question over and over mindlessly.

 

[Into the Night]

I believe you are wrong on this point.

He is correct, Tball.

At least with the Seneca Nation , they are a independent nation and have duel citizenship.
They own their land and only women can own it, men can not own land on the Rez , Men can get life use but when they die it has to go back to a woman .
It is their belief that the blood line comes from the women not men like we do.

It is federal land, like all reservations. It is thanks to the Democrats that indians are put on reservations. Indians call it the Trail of Tears.

 

[Into the Night]

They said Indians owed their allegiance to another sovereign power. Even today where an Indian is born has no Bering on his membership of his tribe. So it did not make any difference where a member of the Winnebago tribe was born he was still a member of the Winnebago tribe. The same is true for Apaches Cherokees etc.

His parents were legal permanent residents and as such were under jurisdiction of the US . The Wong Ark decision even pointed out his parents permanent domicile as the reason for his citizenship. Illegal aliens are subject to immediate removal by deportation so they don't have permanent domicile..

The Pretender is just asking the same question over and over mindlessly. You have already answered him several times. It's like watching an automaton.

 

[Tbird19482]

He is correct, Tball.

It is federal land, like all reservations. It is thanks to the Democrats that indians are put on reservations. Indians call it the Trail of Tears.

Well not being 100% sure I called 2 of my Indian friends and like I said the Seneca are an independent Nation and their people hold duel citizenship's, Seneca and US, ( American ) and according to them they DO own their land and as I said it is the women that own the land NOT the men , Men can not own anything on the Seneca Rez.
If you know different maybe you should tell them , they have only lived it for over 60 years each.

 

[Into the Night]

Well not being 100% sure I called 2 of my Indian friends and like I said the Seneca are an independent Nation and their people hold duel citizenship's, Seneca and US, ( American ) and according to them they DO own their land and as I said it is the women that own the land NOT the men , Men can not own anything on the Seneca Rez.
If you know different maybe you should tell them , they have only lived it for over 60 years each.

Sure, Pretender. Sure. :
Reservations are federal land. Democrats created them, put the indians on them, and caused them to live on welfare.

 

[Tbird19482]

Sure, Pretender. Sure. :
Reservations are federal land. Democrats created them, put the indians on them, and caused them to live on welfare.

Well I am more apt to believe several Indians who LIVE on the Rez and know about their treaty and what is in it and what they can or can not do then a moron like you one a political forum.
And they say they OWN the land it is not Federal land.

 

[Grokmaster]

Birthright citizenship is specifically protected.


View attachment 79864

Please quote the part protecting anchor babies.

 

[Jarod]

Please quote the part protecting anchor babies.

"All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside."

 

[FastLane]

Why does not being here legally affect the government’s jurisdiction? How could they be removed if they aren’t under the government’s jurisdiction?

The same as the government's jurisdiction over American Indians.

 

[FastLane]

Well I am more apt to believe several Indians who LIVE on the Rez and know about their treaty and what is in it and what they can or can not do then a moron like you one a political forum.
And they say they OWN the land it is not Federal land.

THE LAW SAYS THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT OWNS THE LAND ON THE RESERVATION AND HOLDS IT IN TRUST FOR THE INDIANS

Well I am more apt to believe several Indians who LIVE on the Rez and know about their treaty and what is in it and what they can or can not do then a moron like you one a political forum.
And they say they OWN the land it is not Federal land.

They are wrong and that is the reason they cannot sell reservation land. They do not really own it.

AI Overview







View all


Yes, the federal government holds title to most Indian reservation land in trust on behalf of tribes, meaning the land is held by the U.S. government for the beneficial use of Native American nations. While tribes have sovereign authority, reservations are considered federal land areas administered under a trust relationship.