Originally Posted by apple0154 Compassionate conservatism, right? That's what's known as an oxymoron, you moron.
Has nothing to do with Compassionate Conservatism, it has everything to do with common fucking billy-goat sense! You didn't answer my question... How does it benefit Republicans or Conservatives for people to be sick, suffering, dying, miserable? Can you tell me how, or is this just one of those unexplained mysteries rolling around in your empty head?
Stop thinking like a billy-goat and you might understand. It all has to do with "what the market can bear". A manufactured shortage. An example would be if a group of people were dying of thirst in the desert and you had a water truck. You'd sell the water as expensive as possible and, yes, some people would suffer and die while others paid you a lot of money. If no one suffered and died, if everyone got some water, what would your water be worth? That is not a trick question. Just use more than billy-goat sense and you'll figure it out.
More utter stupidity. There are dozens of countries with universal plans that hold free elections. If the population does not like the medical services they vote for people who will change it and there is always, always some politician wanting to make a name for themselves.
Again, WHAT are they supposed to revert back to? There is nothing there! All they can do at this point, is continue to throw money at it and hope to make it better. Most of these countries are having serious problems paying for these programs, and having to now go back and try to reinvigorate capitalist measures to solve the problems they are having. The problem is, once you've successfully killed capitalism, it is hard to get it to return. No investor is going to want to invest in a potential political football like health care... who's to say the people wouldn't change their minds again in a few years, and they lose all their investments again? It's not the most sound financial investment to begin with, but factor in the risk of government rendering you obsolete, and it's a no-brainer... only a fool would invest in a renewed corporate system again.
It's truly wondrous how an individual can have such convoluted thinking. First of all the countries that complain about serious problems paying for universal medical have budgeted less than 1/2 what the US spends. If gas costs $3.00/gallon and I budget $1.50 a gallon, guess what? I'm going to have serious problems paying for gas. (More on the investment aspect below.)
Again, you know nothing about universal plans. Do some research. The people in those countries are happy with their system. Once again, I throw out the challenge. Show me one country where a prominent politician is campaigning on eliminating a universal plan. Just ONE country.
I'm telling you, nitwit... these countries do not have a U.S. Constitution! They do NOT get to make the same decisions WE get to make, with regard to their government or what their government does! It's just NOT the case! And even IF that were the case, there is nothing to revert back to! What would a politician say... I know you hate this government-run system, so I plan to dismantle it and leave you with no health care, because no one wants to invest their money into the industry? I mean, come on, get real, what are they supposed to do if they don't like it? There is no alternative at this point, the alternative is gone.... no more.... never to be again!
Your ignorance concerning how foreign governments work is nothing short of astonishing. (The investment aspect will be dealt with below.)
For God sake, man. What have you been listening to regarding other countries? Or is it a case of not putting down the crack pipe?
No crack pipe, just the realization of the world we live in. You apparently think everyone has the full power of the US Constitution behind them, and are guaranteed certain rights and freedoms in these countries, and you are just plain wrong on that.
Again, your knowledge of foreign governments is appalling.
I'm having difficulty grasping all of it because it's nothing but nonsense. There are investors in Canada lining up to open private medical facilities and that's after having a universal plan for over 40 years.
And if everything is so lovely with the universal plan, WHY is this happening????
The same reason a private consortium will build a toll road near a major city. The public highway is fine but there are always people who want to get to where they're going a little bit faster. The same reason there are luxury hotels constantly being built. It doesn't mean there's no rooms available elsewhere. It's the difference between wanting and needing. The demand for luxury medical accommodation results in denying people who need basic medical accommodation.
Try going to a popular tourist resort area and look for Tom Bodett's Motel 6. Where are the cheap motels overlooking the turquoise waters of the Caribbean? Do the luxury hotel owners care if poor people can't afford a room?
It's the same principal as the water example I gave earlier only no one is going to die if they can't take a vacation. It's the same principal used by medical establishments/facilities.
...There will always, always be people wanting to invest in private medical practice, in some form. Why? Because it's a gold mine. That's why. Whether it's the real estate angle or doctors or nurses there will never be a shortage of investors.
No, it's really NOT a gold mine. Health Care related stock is among the least desired on the exchange. Very small returns for your investment, a very conservative growth rate, and mostly dismal returns quarter after quarter. But still, I am wondering how, in a system where all problems are solved and everyone is happy, why would a commercial venture be attractive? Who wants to pay for something they can get for free? Could it possibly be, because the government-run system isn't all it's cracked up to be? Could it be that people might actually rather pay for care they can receive now instead of having to wait 6 months? It just seems to me, if the universal system is such a good thing, and people are so happy with it, there wouldn't be people trying to commercialize it after 40 years.
You like playing both sides of the fence, don't you? While it may be fun it doesn't do anything for your arguments. First you say people won't invest in medical if the government runs it and then you ask why are people trying to invest in/commercialize it?
So, you do acknowledge there will always be some folks trying to make a buck off the misery of others regardless if the government is involved. Finally, we can put that part of the argument to rest.
Your one ignorant man! In Canada one can see a doctor any time they want, 24 hours a day. If they don't like what the doctor told them they can go see another doctor at another facility. And if they don't like what that doctor told them they can go see another doctor. And another. And another.
And the taxpayer is footing the bill for ALL those visits? First of all, I personally KNOW people from Canada who have come here to the United States for surgeries they couldn't get in Canada within any kind of reasonable time frame. This happens all the time!
And I have seen articles concerning wealthy people going to foreign countries such as Mexico to eat berries and bugs trying to find a cancer cure. Is there a problem with the US, free enterprise, medical system? Where are the berries and bugs?
Do you pay for medical insurance? Instead of paying a company you would pay the government through taxes. Instead of all those medical companies making billions of dollars and their top management getting million dollar bonuses, bonuses your premiums paid for, that money would be put back into the medical plan. It's not just the rich paying. It's everyone paying just as most people now pay a medical insurance company.
See, what you are doing is, working yourself into a frenzy over "rich greedy companies" who you feel have more money than they deserve, and as a way to "punish" them, you're going to take their money and power away and give it to the government!
Health Insurance companies make (on average) a 4% profit per year. Does THAT sound like they are setting the woods on fire? Does it sound like people are getting rich? After taxes, payroll, business expenses, claims, lawsuits, marketing, and indigent care, the health care industry is making a whopping 4% profit! OMG, let's crucify them!
No one is trying to punish the companies. If the government can supply medical care at a reduced rate should they not do so or does the welfare of the companies come first at the expense of the health of US citizens?
Countries do it. Countries with a lot less money.
Socialist countries with dictatorial regimes, where the people die in the streets and nobody gives a shit! And I doubt there are many countries with LESS money than us, we are currently $13 trillion in the hole!
Dying in the streets? I don't know what you've been reading or watching or to whom you've been talking but your lack of knowledge is a sin.
Do some research. You don't know what you're talking about. As I've told you the reason countries do not revert is because the people don't want to. They had it the other way before. They know what it is like. And there's still investors hoping to get a piece of the pie. Or should I say a piece of someones misery and that's who you are supporting. You've been lied to big time. You've been fed crap. Do some serious research.
I've done research, you fraud! People don't revert because there is nothing to revert back to! What part of that are you not comprehending? It's pretty fucking simple... If I run a health insurance business and nobody buys a policy because the government provides the service for free, I can't pay my bills and keep the lights on, so I have to close my insurance business. Once I've done that, wild fucking horses won't be able to drag me back into it again, because chances are, I am financially ruined already.
Hey... I gotta great investment idea... let's sink all our money into a system that the government can arbitrarily decide it wants to take over again on a whim! That's really smart! That's the kind of investment I really want to make! What could possibly go wrong there? You are an idiot who doesn't know the first thing about what you're talking about. You've been spoon fed a bunch of socialist bullshit, and you believe every damn line of it! Nobody can help you, because you are too hard headed to listen to anyone except left-wing propagandists. They've done a great job brainwashing you and other idiots like you, who can't seem to fathom how people want control of their own health care, and do not want to turn that over to the Federal government!
But, but you said people are trying to commercialize it. We settled this aspect of your argument a few paragraphs back.
My goodness, Dixie. You're all mixed up. You're arguing with yourself. Half of your brain is telling you people won't invest in medical if the government is involved and the other half of your brain is telling you people are investing in medical, regardless of government involvement.
Perhaps I can refer you to this site.
http://www.singsurf.org/brain/rightbrain.php
It deals with problems concerning the corpus callosum which contains the neuron fibers that connect both sides of the brain. It appears you may have a malfunction.