Of these dead British generals, does having your aircraft shot down count as being killed in action ? What about having a heart attack ?
Here is a list. Notice, that this is from the largest war the British Empire ever fought, and from 6 years of warfare. Notice all the Brigadiers on the list, a rank down from Major General. Russia has lost 3 Major Generals in less than 3 weeks of a relatively tiny war. Something is going very wrong with the Russian military. All the Russian Major Generals appear to have died from snipers.
Major General Harry Willans, Director General of Welfare and Education, was killed in a fatal accident at El Adem Airfield near Tobruk on February 5, 1943, while on his return journey from India and Assam battlefronts.
Brigadier Grenfell Horace Gerald Smith-Dorrien was killed in action on September 13, 1944 during the Italian campaign.
Major General Wilfred Lewis Lloyd, commanding officer of the Tenth Indian Division, was killed in an air crash in 1944.
Major General Arthur Edward Barstow, commanding officer of the Ninth Indian Division, was killed in an ambush by Japanese troops on January 28, 1942 while trying to cross a demolished bridge near Layang Layang Village in Malaya. At that time, he was trying to contact the Indian 22nd Infantry brigade which had become cut off from the rest of retreating British forces. The Japanese found his body.
Brigadier Vivian Dykes was killed on January 29, 1943, when the engines of his Liberator I Am913 caught fires and crashed on its approach to RAF Base Talbenny from a flight from Casablanca in French Morocco.
Brigadier Herbert Cecil Duncan, commanding officer of the 45th Indian Infantry Brigade was killed while leading a charge in Gwalis during the retreat from Muar River in Malaya on January 16, 1942.
Brigadier John Cecil Currie, commanding officer of the Fourth Armored Brigade, was killed by shellfire on June 26, 1944 after a conference in his headquarters had broken up.
Brigadier Victor Francis Staples Hawkins died of his wounds after he received wound when a bullet from a Japanese sniper ripped into his thigh while he was inspecting his troops in Hill 5120 in Kohima.
Major General Thomas George Gordon Heywood, commanding officer of the 26th Indian infantry Division was killed in an air crash in 1943.
Brigadier Cecil William Haydon, commanding officer of the 150th Infantry Brigade was killed in action on June 1, 1942 in Libya.
Brigadier John Gwynne James, commanding officer of the 36th Brigade was killed in action in Italy in 1944.
Brigadier Hermann Kisch, Chief Engineer of the 8th Army, was killed by a mine explosion near Sousse, Tunisia while inspecting a minefield in 1943.
Brigadier Colin Vyvyan O’Neil McNabb, commanding officer of the 8th Battalion of the Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders, was killed in action in 1943 in North Africa.
Brigadier Gerard Herbert Leo Mole, commanding officer of the 129th Infantry Brigade, died of his wounds in 1943.
Brigadier Clifford Cecil Malden, commanding officer of the 47th Division, was killed by a German bomb.
Brigadier John R. MacIntosh-Wlaker, commanding officer of the 227th Brigade was killed in action in 1944.
Brigadier Thomas Grindall Newbury, commanding officer of the 162nd Brigade, he suffered a heart attack ad died in the afternoon of April 5, 1945.
Lieutenant General Vyvyan Vavasour Pope, commanding officer of the 30th Corps, was killed on October 5, 1941 when his plane was shot down in Egypt.
Brigadier Reginald Gordon Ward Rimington, commander of the 3rd Armored Brigade, died of his wounds received prior to being captured in 1941 in North Africa.
Brigadier Gwynne Brian Sugden, commanding officer of the 158th Brigade was killed in action on January 4, 1945 in France.
Major General Justice Crossland Tilly of the Second Armored Division was killed in action in North Africa in 1941.
Brigadier John Aarundel Theobolds, commanding officer of the Fourth Brigade, died of his wounds in 1941.
Brigadier Robert Allan Grant Taylor, commanding officer of the 35th Brigade, was killed in an air crash in 1942.
Major General Dermot Frederick William warren, commander of the Fifth Indian division was killed in an air crash in 1945 in Burma.
Brigadier Alfred Edward John Cavendish was killed by British artillery fire together with other six men while in Japanese captivity during the bombardment against Indin Village in Maya Peninsula on April 6, 1943.
Major General George Frederick Hopkinson, commanding officer of the First Airborne Division, died of his wounds after he was severely wounded by German machine gun fire during the Sicilian campaign in 1943.
Brigadier Bernard Howlett, commanding officer of the 139th Brigade, was killed in 1943 in North Africa.
Brigadier Dennis Walter Furlong, commanding officer of the Fifth Brigade, was killed in action in France on May 9, 1940.
Brigadier Maxwell Elrington, commanding officer of the 53rd Division, was killed in action in 1945.
Lieutenant General William Henry Ewart Gott , commanding officer of the XIII Corps (and designated to command 8th Army), was killed when his plane was shot down in Egypt.