Abortion Clinic Delivers LIVE baby, places her into Biohazard Bag and thrown out

Watermark said:
How are you guys sure that someone didn't make this up? How did the police obtain a search warrant to go through their trash? This is a southern community, and it has so many hallmarks of a fraudulent southern bigot making shit up I'm surprised no one is thinking of that.
Click to expand...

Well I don't know if I would have phrased it like you did but this does have the smell of an urban legend.

First of all. They don't throw fetuses out in the trash. That's the first hall mark that this is unreliable reporting. Most abortion clinics either have an incinerator on site or have contracts with permitted medical incinerators who would pick up daily.

Second, 23 weeks is at the very lowest limit of viability. It's highly doubtful that this fetus could survive extrauterine.

Third, isn't it ironic that the procedure occurs at 23 weeks, the very last week before the fetus is considered legally viable?

Fourth, the poster has a well known lack of objectivity.

No, this one doesn't pass the smell test.
 
Southern Man said:
Nothing. But being far-left liberal, having an obama avatar or bumper sticker, and driving a Prius is about as much of a cliche as I can imagine.

230738428v39_350x350_Front.jpg
Click to expand...

Well that sure does pale compared to the Nazi flag on your F-150 pick up or is that a confederate flag? It's hard for civilized people to tell the difference between the two.
 
Mottleydude said:
Well I don't know if I would have phrased it like you did but this does have the smell of an urban legend.

First of all. They don't throw fetuses out in the trash. That's the first hall mark that this is unreliable reporting. Most abortion clinics either have an incinerator on site or have contracts with permitted medical incinerators who would pick up daily.

Second, 23 weeks is at the very lowest limit of viability. It's highly doubtful that this fetus could survive extrauterine.

Third, isn't it ironic that the procedure occurs at 23 weeks, the very last week before the fetus is considered legally viable?

Fourth, the poster has a well known lack of objectivity.

No, this one doesn't pass the smell test.
Click to expand...

Here is the story on AP:

http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5jJYykrsdytHiypY5WXf0A7AAY5MAD965JKE00


And here is a link to a site with a copy of the ME's report:

http://operationrescue.org/pdfs/osbourneautopsy.PDF





It looks like a real story.
 
Damocles said:
I think she'll likely be charged, autopsy reports show that the baby filled her lungs with air and was born alive. Almost no courts would allow the argument "she probably would have died anyway".

There is no statute of limitations on murder.
Click to expand...

You're taking a piss poor source as the gospel. The odds are is that even if the baby took a breath more than likely it died in short order. To quickly for any extraordinary efforts to be made. Almost no court would allow that because a fetus is born and takes a breath and dies that it would be murder.
 
Mottleydude said:
You're taking a piss poor source as the gospel. The odds are is that even if the baby took a breath more than likely it died in short order. To quickly for any extraordinary efforts to be made. Almost no court would allow that because a fetus is born and takes a breath and dies that it would be murder.
Click to expand...

The cause of death is listed as "Extreme Prematurity".

But the Dr and the clinic are certainly up for some charges. I don't think disposing of the body in that manner is legal. And, according to the police report, they recovered the decomposing body in a cardboard box.
 
Solitary said:
Here is the story on AP:

http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5jJYykrsdytHiypY5WXf0A7AAY5MAD965JKE00


And here is a link to a site with a copy of the ME's report:

http://operationrescue.org/pdfs/osbourneautopsy.PDF





It looks like a real story.
Click to expand...

Well again, I make the same criticism on the AP report. Poor reporting.

As for the ME report, it's coming from a very questionable source. How do we know that this is the full report/investigation? I'm not trying to set the bar to high here, but you have to admit, Operation Rescue" is hardly an objective observer. Be that as it may, the Coroners report concludes that this was a legal abortion and that the fetus died of extreme prematurity.

Assuming that the reporting here is accurate, and I find these sources questionable and inadequate, then obviously the State of Florida will need to review it's late term abortion procedures.
 
Solitary said:
The cause of death is listed as "Extreme Prematurity".

But the Dr and the clinic are certainly up for some charges. I don't think disposing of the body in that manner is legal. And, according to the police report, they recovered the decomposing body in a cardboard box.
Click to expand...

I tend to agree with you. The abortion was legal but the handling of the fetus very inappropriate. My guess is that the when the event occurred the staff panicked because the Physician wasn't there.
 
Mottleydude said:
Nope. I'm one of them. I just have a problem with rednecked nazi's and their fascist symbols. They give working men and farmers all over a bad name
Click to expand...
Why would you assume that I have a Nazi or Confederate flag on my pickup? Fascism is the natural progression of socialism, socialism the natural progression of liberalism; I am certainly not that.
 
Mottleydude said:
Well again, I make the same criticism on the AP report. Poor reporting.
Click to expand...

The original was an AP report. Why is it poor reporting?

Sounds more like poor reading. You and some others dismiss the source and then invent a fictional account to attempt to make it fit in with your own world view.
 
Mottleydude said:
I tend to agree with you. The abortion was legal but the handling of the fetus very inappropriate. My guess is that the when the event occurred the staff panicked because the Physician wasn't there.
Click to expand...
Did you even read the story?

The owner of the clinic was the one who did this. It wasn't staff.
 
Who cares? So what if it did happen the way the person who is suing says it happened? The infamous "to err is human" report estimated that anywhere from 40 to 100 thousand Americans were being killed every year in hospitals due to malpractice and error.

But cons like Dano say we have to do away with medical malpractice lawsuits anyway. So the tens of thousands of Americans, some children, who are killed every year in the hospitals don't matter, why should this one?

Don't tell me that you freaks are trying to equate this with legal abortion?

because that would just be stupid. You're not all stupid, are you?
 
Darla said:
Who cares? So what if it did happen the way the person who is suing says it happened? The infamous "to err is human" report estimated that anywhere from 40 to 100 thousand Americans were being killed every year in hospitals due to malpractice and error.

But cons like Dano say we have to do away with medical malpractice lawsuits anyway. So the tens of thousands of Americans, some children, who are killed every year in the hospitals don't matter, why should this one?

Don't tell me that you freaks are trying to equate this with legal abortion?

because that would just be stupid. You're not all stupid, are you?
Click to expand...
So far only Watermark has been trying to equate it with that, attempting to defend what happened as "right".
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top