FBI found hundreds of classified files on Petraeus biographer Broadwell’s computer

christiefan915

Catalyst
Contributor
I've posted about Petraeus before but it bears repeating. Let's hear the roars of outrage that this decorated general endangered national security by sharing classified info with his mistress. Let's demand harsher punishment for this lovesick oaf who got away with a slap on the wrist. Let's not pretend this liar betrayed everything he was supposed to stand for and emerged with his reputation intact. Let's hold Betrayus to the same standard we're holding Hillary to. Guess MoveOn had it right after all.

"FBI agents found hundreds of classified documents on Paula Broadwell’s home computers in Charlotte during their investigation into her relationship with then-CIA Director David Petraeus, according to newly unsealed FBI documents obtained by the Observer. More than 300 of those documents were classified as secret, according to a 2013 FBI affidavit accompanying the agency’s request to search Petraeus’ home in Arlington, Va...

The probe uncovered their affair, revealed their mishandling of classified documents and led to Petraeus’ resignation as head of the CIA. Last year, Petraeus pleaded guilty in Charlotte to a misdemeanor charge of mishandling government documents and was fined $100,000. Broadwell, the author of Petraeus’ biography, was never charged. Legal experts say her role as a journalist made any prosecution problematic...

The documents show that when confronted by the FBI, both Broadwell and Petraeus appeared to mislead investigators about their extensive exchange of classified material, most of it involving military and diplomatic operations during Petraeus’ years as commander of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. Broadwell claimed to have gotten some of the documents doing research for her book but “was unable to provide specifics as to how she obtained them ...

Broadwell advised that she never received classified information from Petraeus,” the affidavit says. On the contrary, the new documents include details of multiple emails between the two over classified records, including the “black book” diaries and logs Petraeus kept as commander. In one exchange included in the affidavit, Broadwell told Petraeus that certain records he’d shared were “naturally very helpful ... (I want more of them! I know you’re holding back.)”

In June 2011, the affidavit says she expressed excitement at Petraeus’ willingness to share certain files. “(I)’ll protect them. And I’ll protect you,” she wrote.
During the same conversation, Petraeus referred to some files from his time as Iraqi War commander. “Class’d, but I guess I might share!” he told Broadwell.

http://www.charlotteobserver.com/news/politics-government/article82460877.html
 
he resigned as CIA, and was hounded out of a teaching positon at NYC (?) -all righteous-
so what further punishment would be appropriate?
 
I've posted about Petraeus before but it bears repeating. Let's hear the roars of outrage that this decorated general endangered national security by sharing classified info with his mistress. Let's demand harsher punishment for this lovesick oaf who got away with a slap on the wrist. Let's not pretend this liar betrayed everything he was supposed to stand for and emerged with his reputation intact. Let's hold Betrayus to the same standard we're holding Hillary to. Guess MoveOn had it right after all.

"FBI agents found hundreds of classified documents on Paula Broadwell’s home computers in Charlotte during their investigation into her relationship with then-CIA Director David Petraeus, according to newly unsealed FBI documents obtained by the Observer. More than 300 of those documents were classified as secret, according to a 2013 FBI affidavit accompanying the agency’s request to search Petraeus’ home in Arlington, Va...

The probe uncovered their affair, revealed their mishandling of classified documents and led to Petraeus’ resignation as head of the CIA. Last year, Petraeus pleaded guilty in Charlotte to a misdemeanor charge of mishandling government documents and was fined $100,000. Broadwell, the author of Petraeus’ biography, was never charged. Legal experts say her role as a journalist made any prosecution problematic...

The documents show that when confronted by the FBI, both Broadwell and Petraeus appeared to mislead investigators about their extensive exchange of classified material, most of it involving military and diplomatic operations during Petraeus’ years as commander of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. Broadwell claimed to have gotten some of the documents doing research for her book but “was unable to provide specifics as to how she obtained them ...

Broadwell advised that she never received classified information from Petraeus,” the affidavit says. On the contrary, the new documents include details of multiple emails between the two over classified records, including the “black book” diaries and logs Petraeus kept as commander. In one exchange included in the affidavit, Broadwell told Petraeus that certain records he’d shared were “naturally very helpful ... (I want more of them! I know you’re holding back.)”

In June 2011, the affidavit says she expressed excitement at Petraeus’ willingness to share certain files. “(I)’ll protect them. And I’ll protect you,” she wrote.
During the same conversation, Petraeus referred to some files from his time as Iraqi War commander. “Class’d, but I guess I might share!” he told Broadwell.

http://www.charlotteobserver.com/news/politics-government/article82460877.html

The obvious first response is is he currently running for President? Has Hillary had any actual punishment like Patraus has for her actions?
 
he resigned as CIA, and was hounded out of a teaching positon at NYC (?) -all righteous-
so what further punishment would be appropriate?

Not being honored and acclaimed like he's an elder statesman, for one.

In March 2013, Petraeus accepted the role of Honorary Chairman of the OSS Society.[SUP][201]

Petraeus was named a visiting professor at Macaulay Honors College at the City University of New York in July 2013

On May 1, 2013, the University of Southern California named David Petraeus as a Judge Widney Professor, "a title reserved for eminent individuals from the arts, sciences, professions, business and community and national leadership."
[SUP][205]

Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co. L.P.
, a New York investment firm, hired Petraeus as chairman of the firm's newly created KKR Global Institute in May 2013.

Royal United Services Institute
(RUSI) named Petraeus as a Senior Vice President of the organization in August 2013. According to RUSI, "The honorary role was created by RUSI's trustees and advisory council in recognition of General Petraeus's long association with the Institute and his distinguished contribution to the study and development of defence and international security concepts...
[/SUP]

On February 10, 2014, the University of Exeter in England named Petraeus as an Honorary Visiting Professor of the Strategy and Security Institute.
[/SUP]
 
The obvious first response is is he currently running for President? Has Hillary had any actual punishment like Patraus has for her actions?

I'm incredulous. He's a four-star general who shared classified info-- hundreds of documents--- with a mistress and you seem to think it's less serious than Hillary because he's not running for president. What if Broadwell was a double agent and this was a honey trap?

As far as Hillary, the investigation is still ongoing so it's a little early to talk about punishment.
 
Not being honored and acclaimed like he's an elder statesman, for one.

In March 2013, Petraeus accepted the role of Honorary Chairman of the OSS Society.[SUP][201]

Petraeus was named a visiting professor at Macaulay Honors College at the City University of New York in July 2013

On May 1, 2013, the University of Southern California named David Petraeus as a Judge Widney Professor, "a title reserved for eminent individuals from the arts, sciences, professions, business and community and national leadership."
[SUP][205]

Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co. L.P.
, a New York investment firm, hired Petraeus as chairman of the firm's newly created KKR Global Institute in May 2013.

Royal United Services Institute
(RUSI) named Petraeus as a Senior Vice President of the organization in August 2013. According to RUSI, "The honorary role was created by RUSI's trustees and advisory council in recognition of General Petraeus's long association with the Institute and his distinguished contribution to the study and development of defence and international security concepts...
[/SUP]

On February 10, 2014, the University of Exeter in England named Petraeus as an Honorary Visiting Professor of the Strategy and Security Institute.
[/SUP]

What would you like to see happen to Hillary?
 
I'm incredulous. He's a four-star general who shared classified info-- hundreds of documents--- with a mistress and you seem to think it's less serious than Hillary because he's not running for president. What if Broadwell was a double agent and this was a honey trap?

As far as Hillary, the investigation is still ongoing so it's a little early to talk about punishment.

To be clear since tone can hard to tell I'm staying this context of having a discussion with a friend, not attacking you.

Clearly you are posting this as a defense of some sort for Hillary and isn't it a cop out to say you have no thoughts on what any punishment should be for her? She's running for the highest office in the land.
 
To be clear since tone can hard to tell I'm staying this context of having a discussion with a friend, not attacking you.

Clearly you are posting this as a defense of some sort for Hillary and isn't it a cop out to say you have no thoughts on what any punishment should be for her? She's running for the highest office in the land.

I know you're not attacking me, it's just business.

If she's found guilty she should plead to one misdemeanor charge of handling classified info, get a fine and a little probation, just like Petraeus.
 
Not being honored and acclaimed like he's an elder statesman, for one.
perhaps. but he did design "the surge" which was very effective in the Sunni buy in for Anbar,and Baghdad.
So as a general he was damn good, if not an emeritus as statesman..

++

on the Hillary emails - I've noticed the FBI is focusing on drone warfare info in Pakistan -
it seems to be a big thing it was sent to Clinton ,or it was redacted from the lowside State server....something

here is a link - and I'm thinking it's not enough to indict - but that's just guessing of course

WSJ: Hillary Email Probe Includes Messages About Drone Strikes
http://www.newsmax.com/Newsfront/Hillary-email-drone-strikes/2016/06/09/id/733199/
 
Yep, no double standards. Petraeus's crime didn't prevent him from having a rosy future.

Hold on. Everything you listed Patraeus doing is in the private sector. You think he's going to get a high profile (or any) public sector job again? Hillary can have an amazingingly rosy future in the private sector. But how can you argue this and claim she should still be President?
 
Back
Top