Were his rights violated?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Guns Guns Guns
  • Start date Start date
G

Guns Guns Guns

Guest
Police have arrested an Arizona man who allegedly filmed his 16-year-old nephew walking city streets dressed in a sheet and carrying a fake grenade launcher.



Michael David Turley, 39, was arrested Monday over the making of the video, in which an unidentified narrator says he aims to discover how quickly police in Phoenix would respond following the fatal shooting of 12 people at the screening of the “Dark Knight Rises” Batman movie in Aurora, Colorado, in July.



Made eight days after the shooting at a screening of a Batman movie, the film was posted on YouTube and titled, "Dark Knight Shooting Response, Rocket Launcher Police Test."




"Given this event, I wanted to run a little test here in Phoenix, Arizona," the narrator says in the film. "I want to find out how safe I really am, and I want to know the response time of the Phoenix police department."




The filmmaker claims it took 15 minutes for police to respond. The first officer finds the filmmaker and the teen standing in a driveway. The officer calmly tells the boy to put down the weapon and the man to put down the camera. He didn't draw his gun.




Officer James Holmes, a police spokesman, said Turley told the officer they were just filming a movie, and the officer took down their names and left.



After interviewing people who called 911 and later seeing the video posted on YouTube, police arrested Turley.






[video=youtube;2G3CEvz66ns]http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=2G3CEvz66ns[/video]
 
Well If it was someone else who called 911 then the guy shouldent have been arested.

So you support the rights of Americans to walk the streets wrapped in sheets carrying what appears to be a rocket launcher?
 
That is the stupidest shit I've ever seen. Fucking crazy militia teabaggers have taken over the beautiful state of Arizona!

lol!
 
That is the stupidest shit I've ever seen. Fucking crazy militia teabaggers have taken over the beautiful state of Arizona! lol!

How do you know the filmmaker and his "actor" are "militia teabaggers"?
 
What about the First and Second Amendments?

If you're filming a movie then you need permits.

Would a reasonable person know that the grenade launcher is fake? If people are slowing down to look or because they're freaked out, then it's a problem. The extreme costume and prop could be called disturbing the peace.

I get the point the guy was trying to make (sort of) but this feels like a misfire. Local ordinances for disturbing the peace or disorderly conduct are hard to fight.
 
According to some, a real grenade launcher would be permissible for open carry.
 
Back
Top