"Rich from CA" wanted to know if Barron Trump should be deported.
- Thread starter Diogenes
- Start date
Could trump himself be deported? Without birth right citizenship, trump's citizenship is based on his father's citizenship. Without his father's birth right citizenship, his father's citizenship is based on his parents who lied on their immigration papers. Lying on their immigration papers make them illegal immigrants, much like melania was an illegal immigrant for taking jobs illegally on a tourist visa.
But of course, trump only wants future birth right citizenships to be thrown away.
But of course, trump only wants future birth right citizenships to be thrown away.
T. A. Gardner
Serial Thread Killer
You are a constitutional illiterate.
Article I, Section 9, Clause 3 states that "no Bill of Attainder or ex post facto Law shall be passed."
That means even if Trump passes such a law, it only applies from the day it is passed onward. Those already here and given birthright citizenship will still have it.
trump wants to reinterpret the Constitution to say there was never a right to birthright citizenship... But only going forward. Never means that it was also not there in the past.
By the way, you cannot pass a law replacing the Constitution.
T. A. Gardner
Serial Thread Killer
There is nothing in the constitution about birthright citizenship. That's just a misinterpretation of the 14th Amendment. Clarifying that with a law that says if you're here illegally, or not a citizen, then your child when born here isn't a citizen either. That takes away the unclarity, that's all.
Great, we can deport trump.
T. A. Gardner
Serial Thread Killer
No, you moron, there's that ex-post facto thing.
No, it is a reinterpretation, which is different.
T. A. Gardner
Serial Thread Killer
Doesn't change one whit what I said. No ex-post facto laws.
trump wants to reinterpret the Constitution, which is not an ex post facto law.
The Supreme Court will rule on the 14th Amendment and hopefully will be ruled to not apply to anchor babies.
It's 6-3...poor Walter.
And then we can deport trump, whose only claim to citizenship is based on the supposedly misinterpreted 14th Amendment?
I never understood your claim that there were "anchor babies." Under current law, a "baby" must be at least 21 years old to sponsor a family members application for a visa, so hardly a baby. From Mexico, that application will probably take about 20 years to go through the system, plus seven years residency, which makes 48 years to get citizenship. That is hardly an "anchor."
The reality is that a baby born here gets US citizenship, but the parents of that baby get little. If we take away even the baby's citizenship, then we can finally deport trump.
Its "RICH" indeed for "TheRichFromCali" to be mocking President Trump's immigration policies.
California, right now has some very serious social and economic problems on its hands.
And all of these problems, from punitive progressive taxation, to rampant, middle-claas White Flight, to the faeces be-speckled streets of San Francisco Shitty" are due to insane State immigration policies. Policies that permitted and incentivised the unfettered, un-vetted flood of countless millions Hispanic/Latino illegal immigrants to cross the border into the "Golden State" from Mexico.Those responsible include, for example, Progressive Democrat dickheads like Governor, Jerry ("Moon-Beam") Brown, for instance, who passed legislation making California a "Sanctuary State", and, of course, Gavin Newsome.
For decades to date California's Democrats have endorsed an "open border" immigration policy.
The consequences of this for California have been disastrous.
Trump is far too astute a politician to ever have contemplated anything so F**KING stupid.
Dachshund Dawg
Dachshund the Loyal TRUMPER Hound !!