THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS...

[Melchizedek = Michael]

You can't change your gender by 'identifying' dude.

This is Motherfucking America dude!
We have Freedom!
One of those is Now,in the new PC America, we have the Constitution right to identify with whatever gender we want to!

[gfm7175]

Gender is a role or a social construct.

So you can't even make up your mind as to which one it is?? (hint: it is neither)

For examples:
"The man is doing a woman's job."
"The man throws like a girl."
"The man acts feminine."

Stereotypes have no effect on one's gender. A man is still a man and a woman is still a woman, regardless of whether or not he happens to be a weak soy-boy dental hygienist.

Clearly it does not mean they are biologically female.

Right. The weak soy-boy dental hygienist is STILL A MAN. He still has XY chromosomes. He still has a penis, no matter how small it may be.

[gfm7175]

You have no right to force your definitions on others.

Thread rules are not definitions.

You seem to forget that I've been asking you to define "non-binary person" since my OP and you have yet to do so per the rules stated in the OP.

[AProudLefty]

Thread rules are not definitions.

You seem to forget that I've been asking you to define "non-binary person" since my OP and you have yet to do so per the rules stated in the OP.

I have defined it. Non-binary just means a person doesn't identify as either gender. That is all.

[Into the Night]

Gender is a role or a social construct.

For examples:
"The man is doing a woman's job."
"The man throws like a girl."
"The man acts feminine."

Clearly it does not mean they are biologically female.

Gender is not a role or social construct.
Redefinition fallacy (gender<->society).

[Into the Night]

I just answered it. See post #145.

Nope. You didn't manage to do it. Try again.

[Into the Night]

You have no right to force your definitions on others.

Not his definitions, dumbass.

[AProudLefty]

Not his definitions, dumbass.

You do not get to define words for others and expect them to follow your definitions. You only define for yourself. You only speak for yourself, not others.

[AProudLefty]

Nope. You didn't manage to do it. Try again.

Yes I have. Non-binary simply means a person does not identify as either gender. That is all.

[AProudLefty]

Gender is not a role or social construct.
Redefinition fallacy (gender<->society).

You do not get to define words for others. You only speak for yourself.

[Frank Apisa]

You seem to be forgetting that this is MY thread that I created... I have every right to set rules for responses within my own thread as I see fit. If you don't like my rules, then you can always create your own thread with your own rules. IOW, my thread rules will remain in full force and effect no matter how much it triggers you. There is no "safe space" here.

Define "non-binary person".
Identify and describe a sex other than male or female.
Identify and describe a sex chromosome other than X or Y.

The floor is yours.

Okay. I will stick with my, "You can go fuck yourself you stinking little weasel."

No one can "set rules" except the owner and moderators of the site. You can request that people do certain things...just as I am requesting that you go fuck yourself.

I am delighted that people are laughing at you. It is what you so thoroughly deserve.

[Frank Apisa]

For those of you who actually treat this topic with any sense of realism and decency, today at the MET, Anthony Roth Costanzo will be singing the title role in Philip Glass’s opera, Akhnaten.

Costanzo is a countertenor...and lives a rather ambiguous gender life.

It will be aired on New York's WQXR at 1:00.

If you are not into opera, you might go to YouTube and watch a snippet of Costanzo singing. It truly is something interesting to see and hear.

(That may be a taped performance. I understand my favorite opera, Rigoletto, is being staged instead. The taped performance is on WQXR.)

[Into the Night]

You do not get to define words for others and expect them to follow your definitions. You only define for yourself. You only speak for yourself, not others.

I did not define any word here.

[Into the Night]

Yes I have. Non-binary simply means a person does not identify as either gender. That is all.

That doesn't change his gender. Try again.

[Into the Night]

You do not get to define words for others. You only speak for yourself.

Inversion fallacy. I did not define any word here.