THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS...

[AProudLefty]

You cannot clear your paradoxes by ignoring them, dude.
You must use one and only one of the conflicting arguments and never use the other argument again.

There is no paradox.

[AProudLefty]

Gender is biological.

No it is not. You do not get to redefine the word, dude.

[AProudLefty]

I think a core argument from the left has been identified here:

That 'gender' somehow means something other than the sex of a person, and is instead some kind of psychological disorder, that is somehow a benefit to the person suffering from it. it's ignoring English, of course, and it is often hard to translate Liberal, but this seems to be the current meaning of 'gender' in Liberal.

Psychosychoquackery.

[AProudLefty]

Both words refer to human anatomy and are synonymous in usage.

Feelings and self delusions are not human anatomy.

Define "non-binary person"
Identify and describe a sex other than male or female.
Identify and describe a sex chromosome other than X or Y.

RQAA

[Into the Night]

There is no paradox.

You can't clear your paradoxes by ignoring them, dude.

No it is not. You do not get to redefine the word, dude.

Inversion fallacy.

Psychosychoquackery.

It is YOUR argument. YOU brought it up. Now you call it psychoquackery???!? You are AGAIN denying your own argument???!?

RQAA

Lie. You never answered the questions presented in the OP.

[AProudLefty]

You can't clear your paradoxes by ignoring them, dude.

Inversion fallacy.

It is YOUR argument. YOU brought it up. Now you call it psychoquackery???!? You are AGAIN denying your own argument???!?

Lie. You never answered the questions presented in the OP.

I have answered multiple times. There are no others other than X and Y.

Sex is biological and gender is role.

[Frank Apisa]

You seem to be pretending that 'gender' is not a synonym of 'sex'. You seem to be attempting to redefine the word 'gender' into leftist gibberbabble.

It would do you some good to study etymology.


As you will recall, my question in [2b] asks for a sex chromosome OTHER THAN X or Y, of which you have not provided here and seemingly cannot provide. Ergo, sex (or "gender", if you prefer) is still a BINARY system.


All of this is completely irrelevant and does not provide a sex chromosome other than X or Y.


Abnormalities are not normalities. --- This theoretical person is still male (XY chromosomes, presence of SRY gene). The system is still binary.


Incorrect. It is a simple binary matter. Abnormalities are not normalities.


No, it is not, except for liberals who love to gibberbabble incoherently.


Self delusion and/or feelings do not change biology or anatomy.


Self delusion and/or feelings do not change biology or anatomy.


Feelings are irrelevant.

You have, like all the others, failed to respond in accordance to the rules presented in my OP. Read the rules and try again.

One...fuck your rules.

Two...some people apparently do not feel comfortable with the gender they had at birth...and want to do something about that.

What you ought to do is spend some time scoping out why that matters to you so much. Are you afraid of something?

[gfm7175]

RQAA

Mockery. Evasion.

[gfm7175]

One...fuck your rules.

This is my thread, so my rules will be adhered to. If you wish to operate under your own rules, then make your own thread. My thread will be following my rules, as written in the OP.

Two...some people apparently do not feel comfortable with the gender they had at birth...and want to do something about that.

Feelings are irrelevant, and gender cannot be changed. You are what you are. Deal with it.

What you ought to do is spend some time scoping out why that matters to you so much. Are you afraid of something?

No, but apparently YOU are afraid of answering my questions per my rules within the OP. Why is that?

Science doesn't give a fuck about your feelings, dude.

[AProudLefty]

Mockery. Evasion.

There is no evasion. I have answered your questions as per your rules.

[AProudLefty]

This is my thread, so my rules will be adhered to. If you wish to operate under your own rules, then make your own thread. My thread will be following my rules, as written in the OP.


Feelings are irrelevant, and gender cannot be changed. You are what you are. Deal with it.


No, but apparently YOU are afraid of answering my questions per my rules within the OP. Why is that?

Science doesn't give a fuck about your feelings, dude.

Biological sex cannot be changed.

[gfm7175]

There is no evasion. I have answered your questions as per your rules.

No you haven't. Stop lying.

[AProudLefty]

No you haven't. Stop lying.

Yes I have. See posts #12, #19, #27, #31, #37, #50, #62, #68, #70, #76, #88, #97, #111 and #116.

[gfm7175]

I think a core argument from the left has been identified here:

That 'gender' somehow means something other than the sex of a person, and is instead some kind of psychological disorder, that is somehow a benefit to the person suffering from it. it's ignoring English, of course, and it is often hard to translate Liberal, but this seems to be the current meaning of 'gender' in Liberal.

This is the best that I can come up with as well.

They keep talking about "feelings" and "identifying as [something other than what they biologically are]", so I concur with your conclusion that 'gender', in Liberal, at least for the time being, must be a vague reference to some sort of psychological disorder. Liberal seems to never have any clear word definitions like English has, and there sure are a lot of buzzwords that I have noticed them use with regard to sex/gender.

I unfortunately don't have them all included on my Lispy Leftist List (who can keep up with these freaks??!!), but here is what I have so far with regard to this topic... Yes, these are all meaningless words that I have personally witnessed liberals use, thinking that they are actually saying something intelligent:

embodying all genders
full(y) female
full(y) male
gender
gender equality
gender fluid(ity)
gender identity
gender inclusive / gender inclusivity
gender neutral(ity)
gender non-binary
genderqueer
gender questioning
gender sense
gender spectrum
gender studies
human body spectrum
partial(ly) female
partial(ly) male
sexual identity
traditional binary opposition (male/female)
transition(ed)(ing) (male/female)

[gfm7175]

Biological sex cannot be changed.

Yup, that's what I said.