Federal judge blocks California law requiring Trump tax returns

[OG Yurt]

He also hates facts, the truth, being honest....Arsecheese has a long list.

Indeed.

[ziggy]

Tell us again, why does Trump feel the need breaking precedent to make sure no one ever sees his income tax returns?

Because democrats just want to politicize the fact that he took advantage of loopholes to pay less taxes. If there was anything illegal there the IRS would've dealt with it long ago.

[Micawber]

Got to admit Trumptard's fanboys have a lot to be happy about regarding basically winning so many legal arguments that allow the fat pig mafia boss
to run an opaque banana republic crime syndicate....

[countryboy]

Yurtski the Constitutional expert

It doesn't take an expert to see this is unconstitutional. The Constitution lays out specific requirements to be elected president, and financial records aren't one of them. But please, by all means, cry harder.

[PostmodernProphet]

right wing goobs love Trump's lawlessness, admire the trait

oh well, a GWB appointee rules as expected...…...appeals court here we come

Trump appointees.......oops.......

[Mason Melchizedek]

It doesn't take an expert to see this is unconstitutional. The Constitution lays out specific requirements to be elected president, and financial records aren't one of them. But please, by all means, cry harder.

I claimed nothing but that Yurtski was a Constitutional expert!

[countryboy]

I claimed nothing but that Yurtski was a Constitutional expert!

It's implied in your ad hominem attack.

[archives]

The Constitution; read it.

Tell us again why Trump must be compelled to do something he is not Constitutionally required to do?

How can the Constitution specific income tax when the latter didn't even come about till a century or so later?

And now you are going to say it isn't there so it isn't a requirement, but no one is saying it is mandatory, rather, why doesn't Trump release his taxes, what is he hiding?

The President is responsible for the tax policy every American has to follow, and you don't think it is unreasonable for Americans who fund his million dollar golf junkets to Florida to see how the President meets his civic responsibilities?

[Truth Detector]

Because democrats just want to politicize the fact that he took advantage of loopholes to pay less taxes. If there was anything illegal there the IRS would've dealt with it long ago.

Correct; isn't it fascinating how leftists are too stupid to comprehend that REALITY.

[Truth Detector]

Got to admit Trumptard's fanboys have a lot to be happy about regarding basically winning so many legal arguments that allow the fat pig mafia boss
to run an opaque banana republic crime syndicate....

Cry harder you sad, pathetic piece of human debris.

[Truth Detector]

How can the Constitution specific income tax when the latter didn't even come about till a century or so later?

Were you stoned when you typed this word salad Arsecheese? If it is NOT a requirement, then it is NOT a requirement. This is only rocket science for idiots and morons.

And now you are going to say it isn't there so it isn't a requirement,

And now you are going to say that if it isn't there, it should be a requirement. Do you ever read your bullshit and comprehend how dumb YOU look?

but no one is saying it is mandatory, rather, why doesn't Trump release his taxes, what is he hiding?

Apparently you leftist dumb fucks are attempting to argue it should be mandatory. The FACT remains that it is not required. It is against the law for anyone to obtain ANYONE'S tax records unless there is a criminal case and then, ONLY the IRS and law enforcement can obtain those records.

Now, let's touch on the tax forms themselves. As one of the richest men in America, and the fact that his returns are most likely very complicated, Trumps returns are very likely audited every damn year. If there is illegality, it surely would have been born out in these audits.

Secondly, have you ever seen a tax form other than 1040EZ? They don't contain information that would suggest anything more than his income, his deductions and taxes paid.

Lastly, the main reason it is none of your business or the assholes in the Democratic Party of the Jackass and Phony media's is simple; they only want it to continue their pathological attacks on this man. Nothing more. So NO, you can't have them. Cry harder about it.

The President is responsible for the tax policy every American has to follow, and you don't think it is unreasonable for Americans who fund his million dollar golf junkets to Florida to see how the President meets his civic responsibilities?

That has to be the lamest, dumbest argument I have ever seen for prying into someone's personal business. I'll expect you low IQ leftists to cry about every trip ANY President takes for the rest of your lives. Just like you said NOTHING for eight years of record breaking deficits under Obama.

Again, that is NONE of your business and when you stop being a two faced hypocrite on steroids, maybe we will find some common ground.

[archives]

Were you stoned when you typed this word salad Arsecheese? If it is NOT a requirement, then it is NOT a requirement. This is only rocket science for idiots and morons.

And now you are going to say that if it isn't there, it should be a requirement. Do you ever read your bullshit and comprehend how dumb YOU look?

Apparently you leftist dumb fucks are attempting to argue it should be mandatory. The FACT remains that it is not required. It is against the law for anyone to obtain ANYONE'S tax records unless there is a criminal case and then, ONLY the IRS and law enforcement can obtain those records.

Now, let's touch on the tax forms themselves. As one of the richest men in America, and the fact that his returns are most likely very complicated, Trumps returns are very likely audited every damn year. If there is illegality, it surely would have been born out in these audits.

Secondly, have you ever seen a tax form other than 1040EZ? They don't contain information that would suggest anything more than his income, his deductions and taxes paid.

Lastly, the main reason it is none of your business or the assholes in the Democratic Party of the Jackass and Phony media's is simple; they only want it to continue their pathological attacks on this man. Nothing more. So NO, you can't have them. Cry harder about it.

That has to be the lamest, dumbest argument I have ever seen for prying into someone's personal business. I'll expect you low IQ leftists to cry about every trip ANY President takes for the rest of your lives. Just like you said NOTHING for eight years of record breaking deficits under Obama.

Again, that is NONE of your business and when you stop being a two faced hypocrite on steroids, maybe we will find some common ground.

Amazing, he breaks it down per phrase and still gets it wrong

Never said it was a requirement nor did I say it was mandatory, which you verified with your "apparently" preface, but that didn't stop you from fabricating a bogus arguement to attack, as I said, always humorous

Next we have the complicated rich guy defense, did you ever ask yourself why Trump has never delivered any proof that his taxes are actually being audited? The IRS by law can not comment on an individual's taxes, anything Trump says about his returns are just Trump's word for it, and everyone knows he is an honest guy

Not true, tax returns have a wealth of information, how the person got down to his AGI figure alone says a lot

And it is ironic how you didn't offer one item to invalidate that "lamest, dumbest argument" other than calling it the "lamest, dumbest argument." Kinda like, "cause I said so," and we all know how valid why you say is