Settled law and stare decisis

[Micawber]

You aren't a lawyer. I am. Your opinions are meaningless. A null set. This thread doesn't even exist!

You wouldn't know stare decisis from staring at your cousin's tramp stamp, rube.

[canceled.2021.2]

This is a good example of the ignorance of the right wing. SCOTUS does not write laws. They interpret laws according to the Constitution. Of course, KillerText does not understand the difference between "interpret", and "Write", anymore then TiffyDon understands the concept of "settled".

Where in the US Constitution was the Supreme Court given the power to interpret the Constitution?

[canceled.2021.2]

Heller and Citizens United are settled law

[Lesh]

You aren't a lawyer. I am. Your opinions are meaningless. A null set. This thread doesn't even exist!

You wouldn't know stare decisis from staring at your cousin's tramp stamp, rube.

Is it your contention that a majority of justices can't change ANY decision made previously?

If it is..you are no lawyer

[Micawber]

Is it your contention that a majority of justices can't change ANY decision made previously?

If it is..you are no lawyer

You think if I say something that's not true I'm not a lawyer? I daresay you are not a lawyer. LMFAO

checkmate.

[Lesh]

Heller and Citizens United are settled law

And can be overturned like any other decision.

Why in the hell would ANYONE support Citizen's United anyway?

[Lesh]

You think if I say something that's not true I'm not a lawyer? I daresay you are not a lawyer. LMFAO

checkmate.

Dude if you think that Justices can't overturn just about any SC decision if they have the majority...you aren't a very GOOD lawyer anyway.

[Micawber]

And can be overturned like any other decision.

Why in the hell would ANYONE support Citizen's United anyway?

Yes and no. Things that can be overturned, we are in the realm of very narrow.
There is the law. It's not like a clean slate

[Micawber]

Dude if you think that Justices can't overturn just about any SC decision if they have the majority...you aren't a very GOOD lawyer anyway.

Bullshit. You left yourself some wiggle room however.

Let me know when Marbury v Madison is overturned. The law is sedimentary rock.

Be amazed now, quote me later.

[PostmodernProphet]

Of course law may be that settled.

If the super majority of society thinks X is so, SCOTUS won't go with Y.

is that really your standard?.......once upon a time a super majority thought separate but equal was a solution.........once upon a time a super majority believed that marriage meant the union of a man and a woman........once upon a time a super majority thought killing your unborn children was a bad thing.........

[Lesh]

Bullshit. You left yourself some wiggle room however.

Let me know when Marbury v Madison is overturned. The law is sedimentary rock.

Be amazed now, quote me later.

So your claim is that Roe can't be overturned?

[Micawber]

So your claim is that Roe can't be overturned?

No. I attacked your silly proclamation, not the judicial tensile strength of Roe.

Try again.

[Damocles]

I don't disagree with you.

Stare Decisis is a fantasy that has only occasionally been honored.

Roe V Wade is absolutely in jeopardy

This is what you get when you have Republicans running anything

Forget that at your peril

What do you think would happen if Roe v Wade was overturned? (It won't be, John Roberts has spent many long years setting himself up to become the "new Kennedy", so no change of balance will happen).

[Lesh]

What do you think would happen if Roe v Wade was overturned? (It won't be, John Roberts has spent many long years setting himself up to become the "new Kennedy", so no change of balance will happen).

You're relying on ROBERTS to save Roe?

Good fucking luck

[Damocles]

You're relying on ROBERTS to save Roe?

Good fucking luck

I'm not relying on anybody to save anything. I'm not particularly worried about Roe v. Wade. I notice you didn't answer the question.

What do you think would happen if Roe v. Wade was overturned?