The Supreme Court faces an existential crisis of legitimacy

Dude, all you do is look as crazy as Sybil when you say shit like that.
Psychoquackery. You made up Sybil. If you want to make him crazy, that's YOUR fantasy.
Just because I wasn't with the mob trying to hang Pence
No one was trying to hang Pence. Hallucination.
and murder all of Congress
No one was trying to murder all of Congress. Hallucination.
doesn't mean I wouldn't pick up arms against enemies of the Constitution, foreign and domestic.
You deny and discard the Constitution of the United States.
Only a deluded moron thinks "the Democrats are coming to take our guns today so we need to overthrow the government NOW!!!!"
Democrats ARE trying to take guns away. That is unconstitutional.
 
Where in the Constitution does the Federal government have that power? The woman is an American citizen. The zygote or blastocyst is only a potential citizen yet you are asserting the "rights" of a potential citizen override the rights of a living, breathing adult American citizen.

By what logic have you arrived at this decision? It strikes me to be almost purely religious.

how is that baby not alive ?
its constantly growing, heart is pumping blood, it responds to stimuli.
nothing in the Constitution about it being wrong to murder people but we basically adopted English Common Law which does address that among many other things. Its a pretty good template as it reflects behavious that are universally seen as wrong.
you see to prize convenience over right and wrong. pretty scary that.
 
Where in the Constitution does the Federal government have that power?
It doesn't. States do though. They have authority to pass laws concerning homicide.
The woman is an American citizen.
So?
The zygote or blastocyst is only a potential citizen yet you are asserting the "rights" of a potential citizen override the rights of a living, breathing adult American citizen.
It is a human being.
By what logic have you arrived at this decision? It strikes me to be almost purely religious.
RQAA. This has already been explained to you.
 
if you plan on trying that, better serpentine...
and hope the other guy is a terrible shot.

...and buy body armor for one's ass and back.

They were all idiots out that night except for the KPD.
 
Last edited:
the idiots in Roe used the first amendment (speech) as the criteria for making it legal.

Only partially. They used the "other rights" in the 9th Amendment and said if we have other rights not listed in the first 8 one is the right to privacy. They supported that by citing other rights designed to protect our privacy: 1st-freedom of assembly, 3rd-quartering of troops, 4th-search and seizure, 5th-right to remain silent. They used the 14th Amendment due process clause to make these rights applicable to the states.

So, they used the 1st amendment freedom of assembly clause but not the free speech clause. Free speech does not really apply to privacy.
 
Why do you believe the Federal or state government should control a person's body?

The already control your body--age of alcohol consent, hours of alcohol purchase, what drugs you can put into your body, age of consent for sexual activity, vaccinations required for school and military duty...
 
The already control your body--age of alcohol consent, hours of alcohol purchase, what drugs you can put into your body, age of consent for sexual activity, vaccinations required for school and military duty...

A lot of those things are religious based morality laws. Limits for public safety are fine such as "No shooting guns in town". Why should anyone give a damn if I buy beer on a Sunday morning unless it's a religious issue?
 
A lot of those things are religious based morality laws. Limits for public safety are fine such as "No shooting guns in town". Why should anyone give a damn if I buy beer on a Sunday morning unless it's a religious issue?

They are still laws even if they were (originally) religious based. Many laws are religious based morality laws--murder, rape, assault, theft....

At one time adultery and sodomy were illegal.
 
They are still laws even if they were (originally) religious based. Many laws are religious based morality laws--murder, rape, assault, theft....

At one time adultery and sodomy were illegal.
Exactly, because they were religious-based. Let's keep moving in that direction.

Murder and rape or any other victim crimes secular.
 
Exactly, because they were religious-based. Let's keep moving in that direction.

Murder and rape or any other victim crimes secular.

Laws on alcohol consumption (including blue laws) were never found unconstitutional because of 1st amendment freedom of religion. They were eventually repealed by the legislature or struck down for violating the right to privacy (sodomy).

Do you think drug laws are religiously based? A law can be based on the religious beliefs of some (abortion) but it is still a secular law if it contains no religious language.
 
Laws on alcohol consumption (including blue laws) were never found unconstitutional because of 1st amendment freedom of religion. They were eventually repealed by the legislature or struck down for violating the right to privacy (sodomy).

Do you think drug laws are religiously based? A law can be based on the religious beliefs of some (abortion) but it is still a secular law if it contains no religious language.

Yes. What right does a government have to tell a person they can't be a heroin addict?

If we all have unalienable rights, then where does it become the government's right to dictate to someone they can't smoke pot?
 
Yes. What right does a government have to tell a person they can't be a heroin addict?

If we all have unalienable rights, then where does it become the government's right to dictate to someone they can't smoke pot?

The 10th Amendment gives the states "police powers" to protect "health, safety, welfare, and morals." Federal laws against drugs come from the interstate commerce clause.

That "inalienable rights" thing was always a little vague to me--like "natural law."
 
What do the rights of the unborn include? Do they have the right to make contracts, inherit....?

If a fetus is a person, try and get it a social security card . register it for the draft. Try and good food stamps. They will show you that is not a person.
 
The 10th Amendment gives the states "police powers" to protect "health, safety, welfare, and morals." Federal laws against drugs come from the interstate commerce clause.

That "inalienable rights" thing was always a little vague to me--like "natural law."

I understand they are laws. What I don't understand is what gives a democratic government oppressive authoritarian powers...except that We, the People gave it to them and won't take them back.
 
I understand they are laws. What I don't understand is what gives a democratic government oppressive authoritarian powers...except that We, the People gave it to them and won't take them back.

The government has the powers given it in the Constitution. Technically, in a democracy the government has any powers a majority of the people choose to give it. That is why many make the point that we are not a democracy because a majority cannot override the rights of the minority in our system.
 
Back
Top